Teodoro runs a 60-person engineering firm in Roseville, with 40 people in California and 20 in a Reno office. His $120,000 design-software subscription renews February 1, 2027, and the renewal quote now adds California tax on all 60 seats. (Teodoro and his numbers are illustrative.)
I covered the statute in September in California Will Tax SaaS on January 1, 2027. This post is about the rules the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) drafted to run it, which decide whether he pays on 60 seats or 40.
Are California’s SaaS tax regulations final yet?
No. CDTFA released draft Regs. 1502.2, 1600, 1600.1, 1600.2 and 1600.3, plus amendments to Regs. 1502, 1507 and 1699.6, in a September 1, 2026 discussion paper and closed comments September 24. Section 34 of SB 122 (Stats. 2026, ch. 23) allows emergency regulations that last two years and can be readopted. As of October 23, the Office of Administrative Law’s review list shows no CDTFA filing and nothing has been approved. Treat everything below as draft text that can change. The tax starts January 1 regardless.
Which address decides where a California software sale is taxed?
Amended R&TC § 6010.5(b), repeated in draft Reg. 1600(d), sources remote software to the seller’s own California location only when the buyer purchases face to face at a place that needs a seller’s permit. Otherwise it goes to the buyer’s known California address in the seller’s records: billing first, then shipping, then the payment card’s address, then mailing. Only California addresses are ranked.
A Sacramento company whose customer gives only a Nevada billing address has no California address to use. The law then treats the sale as made outside California, and new § 6054 protects a seller that tried to collect complete addresses. But if that customer’s users sit in California, § 6010.5.1 puts the use where the person logging in is and presumes use within 90 days means it was bought for use here. The customer owes use tax itself. For a California buyer with staff in three states, the reverse happens: its California billing address pulls in the whole subscription.
Draft Reg. 1600(c) sorts sales tax from use tax. Sales tax needs “some genuine physical human interaction with the sale” from one of the seller’s California business locations. For a software company with one Irvine office and reps working from home, a rep’s visit to a client is a sales tax sale and an online signup is a use tax sale the company still collects. A video demo from Irvine, or a rep’s home office, is not addressed. Buyers care because use tax stays the buyer’s debt under § 6202 until the seller gives a receipt. The local rate follows the address either way: Reg. 1802 normally sends local tax to the seller’s office, but §§ 7202.1 and 7254 route local and district tax on remote digital sales through the § 6010.5(b) rules.
How does a multiple-points-of-use certificate split tax for out-of-state staff?
Draft Reg. 1600.2 implements § 6372(e). A buyer whose employees or agents use the same product at the same time in California and elsewhere, and who knows it when buying, can give the seller a multiple-points-of-use (MPU) certificate. Any reasonable, consistently applied method backed by the buyer’s books works. Counting users or computers is presumed reasonable. Counting server locations is not, which fits the statute’s rule that access happens where the person is.
A signed, dated letter or purchase order qualifies if it also identifies the buyer and its CDTFA account (or why it has none), describes the product, and states the taxable and nontaxable amounts and the method. The seller must have it before billing, within its billing cycle, or by first access. The buyer keeps the seat records. Two catches: apportioning switches off the § 6406 credit for another state’s tax under § 6372(e)(2), and an MPU certificate is different from the Reg. 1600.3 certificate for software used only outside California.
Who has to self-assess under California’s $5 million SaaS rule?
Very few buyers. Under §§ 6052 and 6201.55 and draft Reg. 1600.1, the shift comes when one vendor’s remote digital product sales to one purchaser pass $5,000,000 in 2027, or from 2028 in the current or prior year. The buyer reports starting at the purchase that crosses the line. A $3 million renewal taking a buyer from $4 million to $7 million with one vendor is the buyer’s to report in full, and that buyer opens 2028 already over.
The buyer needs a use tax direct payment permit under § 7051.3 and gives that vendor an exemption certificate, which draft Reg. 1699.6 says a second vendor still under $5 million cannot accept in good faith. The alternative is a waiver request emailed to CDTFA before buying, listing the places of first use; if granted, the vendor collects and those places become the place of sale. Insurers are excluded. The draft defines purchaser as a “person,” so I read affiliates that sign separately as separate purchasers, though nothing says so.
Do custom software, patent licenses and AI tools stay outside the tax?
Custom software does. Draft Reg. 1502.2 carries forward Reg. 1502(f)(2): software written to one customer’s order is untaxed, and changes to prewritten software are exempt only if billed separately. In the draft’s example, $10,000 of software plus a separately billed $5,000 rewrite is taxed on $10,000, while a $15,000 lump sum is taxed in full.
Patent and copyright licenses are the open question. R&TC §§ 6011(c)(10) and 6012(c)(10) exclude the price of intangibles transferred with tangible property under a technology transfer agreement (TTA), a license to make and sell a product or use a process. Nortel Networks Inc. v. State Bd. of Equalization (2011) 191 Cal.App.4th 1259 applied that to prewritten switch software, and Lucent Technologies, Inc. v. State Bd. of Equalization (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 19 held a right to copy software onto equipment enough, affirming a $24.5 million refund. SB 122 left those statutes alone but made a digital product “and any copyright or patent interests associated therewith” tangible property, and the discussion paper says Reg. 1507’s TTA treatment no longer reaches prewritten software. Whether any intangible remains to exclude is unresolved. I would not price a 2027 license on the old result without a written ruling.
AI tools get no special pass: the draft’s example says outputs of an AI tax tool trained on California law are not custom software, because the model is sold to many customers. For consultants, § 6372.1 exempts mostly human work begun after the client asked. An engineer’s report delivered through a portal remains a service; selling log-ins to the firm’s own software does not qualify.
What should a Roseville business do before its first 2027 renewal?
Back to Teodoro (illustrative). His $380,000 stack covers 14 vendors, all assumed to be taxable SaaS billed to Roseville, where CDTFA’s October 1, 2026 rate table shows 7.75 percent. Taxed on every seat, a year of it carries $29,450. The February renewal is fully taxable, because draft Reg. 1600(f)(2)(B) taxes subscription periods after January 1 whenever paid: $9,300 on 60 seats, or $6,200 with an MPU certificate for 40. The same 40-of-60 split across all 14 vendors brings the year to about $19,633, a saving near $9,817.
Two small out-of-state vendors billing $18,000 fall under the $500,000 California sales trigger in § 6203 and will not collect. Teodoro owes use tax on the California share, $12,000, or $930. Over $10,000, he registers as a qualified purchaser (covered in September) and files by April 15, 2028. His largest vendor bills $120,000; the $5 million rules never reach him.
For buyers, list every subscription by vendor, renewal date and seat location, confirm each vendor’s billing address, and send MPU certificates before the January and February invoices. Under the draft, a one-time license with access before January 1 stays untaxed even if paid later. Resellers give resale certificates under Reg. 1668, and reproduction rights are exempt under § 6362.4. Sellers should register, watch for the update CDTFA promised to its digital products guide, and say “plus applicable taxes,” since Civ. Code § 1656.1 presumes reimbursement was agreed only when the contract or invoice shows it.
| Draft rule | What it governs | Matters most to | Certificate or form | Open as of Oct. 23, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reg. 1502.2 | Custom software and modifications | Sellers, developers | Separately stated invoice line | AI outputs; effect on TTAs |
| Reg. 1600 | Definitions, sales vs. use tax, sourcing, timing | Every seller and buyer | None | What counts as in-person participation |
| Reg. 1600.1 | $5 million vendor-by-vendor shift | Enterprise buyers | Direct payment permit, exemption certificate or waiver | Affiliates; waiver timing |
| Reg. 1600.2 | Apportioning concurrent multistate use | Small and mid-size buyers | MPU certificate | No blanket certificate |
| Reg. 1600.3 | Software used only outside California | Buyers with no California users | Exemption certificate | CDTFA form not yet issued |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are California’s SaaS tax regulations in effect?
Not yet. As of October 23, 2026 they are CDTFA drafts that have not been filed with or approved by the Office of Administrative Law. The SB 122 tax starts January 1, 2027 whether or not the regulations are adopted by then.
Can I split SaaS tax by where the servers are?
No. The draft MPU rule treats a server-location method as unreasonable. Counting users or computers inside and outside California is presumed reasonable.
Does an out-of-state billing address keep a subscription out of California tax?
It can relieve the seller, but not the buyer. Software accessed by people in California is used here, and software bought elsewhere but used here within 90 days is presumed bought for use here. The buyer then owes use tax directly.
Does the $5 million rule apply to a small business?
Only if a single vendor sells it more than $5 million of digital products in a year. Purchases from different vendors are not added together.
Is AI software trained on California rules custom software?
Not under the draft. CDTFA’s example treats outputs of a general AI model sold to many customers as prewritten software, even when the results look tailored.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm helps California businesses sort their software spend, prepare MPU and exemption certificates and register through its sales tax and payroll tax practice, and it rewrites subscription terms through contract drafting and review. Its tax defense practice handles CDTFA audits and appeals to the Office of Tax Appeals. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Tax Court.
If a renewal quote just added California tax, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before the invoice goes out.
