North Star Law Firm logoNorth Star Law Firm
☰

California Divorce Taxes After SB 711: Spousal Support, the House and the Business

Grand homes in the Pacific Heights neighborhood of San Francisco, California, the family residence that is often the largest asset divided in a divorce

Written by

in

Daniela lives in Redlands. She separated from her husband in March 2026, and his lawyer proposes $4,500 a month of spousal support for six years. A friend says California “still lets him deduct it.” For judgments signed from 2019 through 2025, yes. For hers, no. (Daniela and every figure here are illustrative.)

Federal primers miss what decides a California case: community property law and the Franchise Tax Board’s own rules. I am not a family lawyer; I do the tax and forensic accounting work the family lawyer relies on before anything is signed.

Is spousal support still deductible on a California tax return?

Only under an instrument signed before 2026. Federal law repealed IRC §§ 71 and 215 for instruments executed after 2018, but California kept the old rules because its code followed the Internal Revenue Code as of January 1, 2015. SB 711 (Ch. 231, Stats. 2025) moved that date to January 1, 2025 in R&TC § 17024.5 and adopted the repeal going forward. Under the FTB’s 2025 Schedule CA (540) instructions, payments “are not includable in the income of the receiving spouse and are not deductible by the payor spouse if made under any divorce or separation agreement executed after December 31, 2025.”

Pre-2019 instruments stay deductible and taxable on both returns. Instruments signed from 2019 through 2025 stay that way in California only: the recipient reports the support on Schedule CA (540), line 2a, column C, and the payor deducts it on line 19a, column C.

Modifications are the trap. A 2019 to 2025 instrument modified later keeps its California treatment unless the modification “expressly provides that the amendments apply,” so silence preserves the deduction. The old section 71 conditions in IRS Publication 504 still police it, including termination at the recipient’s death and third-year recapture when payments fall by more than $15,000.

The state benefit was always small. On $54,000 of support, a payor in California’s 9.3 percent bracket ($72,724 to $371,479 of 2025 single taxable income) saves about $5,022, and a recipient in the same bracket owes nearly that. In the 11.3 percent bracket ($445,771 to $742,953) the saving tops out at $6,102. Fam. Code § 4320(j) has the court weigh “the immediate and specific tax consequences to each party”; for 2026 and later judgments, support is after-tax money on both returns.

Who pays the old joint tax bills after a California divorce?

On a joint return, the IRS can collect from either spouse, whatever the judgment says. Under IRC § 6015(c), a spouse who is divorced, legally separated or out of the household for 12 months can limit liability to his or her own items, electing within two years after collection begins. Equitable relief under (f) is the fallback, and Rev. Proc. 2013-34 counts a decree assigning the debt solely to your former spouse in your favor, unless you knew they would not pay.

California mirrors section 6015 in R&TC § 18533 (the request is form FTB 705), then goes further. Under Fam. Code § 2628 and R&TC § 19006(b), the family court can revise joint California liability, binding the FTB once served. The order must state each year separately and cannot shift tax on a spouse’s own earnings. Above $150,000 of gross income or $7,500 of relief, it also needs an FTB tax revision clearance certificate.

Is your California divorce settlement being negotiated right now? Test the support terms and asset basis before the judgment is entered, because the signed instrument fixes the tax result and undoing it takes a new order.

How is income split in the year a California couple separates?

By the date of separation. Fam. Code § 771 makes earnings after that date separate property. Fam. Code § 70 defines it as a “complete and final break,” shown by expressed intent and consistent conduct, and expressly abrogates In re Marriage of Davis (2015) 61 Cal.4th 846. The date fixes the tax split too.

IRC § 66(a) overrides community rules only for spouses who lived apart all year and filed separately. After a March separation, IRS Publication 555 applies state law: on separate returns, each spouse reports half the community wages earned before the separation date, with Form 8958. California requires the same filing status (R&TC § 18521(a)), and a spouse unaware of the other’s income can seek relief under section 66(c) or R&TC § 18534.

Are property transfers in a California divorce really tax-free?

When made, yes. Under IRC § 1041, transfers between spouses, or to a former spouse incident to divorce, trigger no gain, and the recipient keeps the transferor’s basis; Treas. Reg. § 1.1041-1T covers transfers under the judgment within six years. Tax waits for a sale.

For the house, R&TC § 63 excludes a transfer under a property settlement or dissolution decree from reassessment, so the Prop 13 base survives. California follows section 121 through R&TC § 17152, and IRC § 121(d)(3)(B) treats an owner as using the home while a former spouse occupies it under a divorce instrument. The spouse who moved out can keep his own $250,000 exclusion if he stays on title.

A business is harder. In re Marriage of Fonstein (1976) 17 Cal.3d 738 refused to discount value for taxes absent an “immediate and specific tax liability,” so the spouse who keeps a low-basis S corporation usually keeps its latent gain. The parties can agree to tax-affect the numbers, but only before judgment.

Retirement plans divide under a qualified domestic relations order (QDRO) meeting IRC § 414(p). Cash paid to the former spouse escapes the 10 percent early-withdrawal tax under IRC § 72(t)(2)(C) and California’s 2.5 percent tax under R&TC § 17085(c), though not income tax. IRAs move under IRC § 408(d)(6) without that exception (section 72(t)(3)(A)), so needed cash should come from the plan.

What would this look like for a Redlands couple divorcing in 2027?

Illustrative facts: Daniela and her husband, with no minor children, separated March 15, 2026 and expect a 2027 judgment. He earns $260,000 in wages and owns a consulting S corporation formed during the marriage; she earns $70,000. The house carries $450,000 of gain.

Signed in 2027, the $54,000 of annual support is neither deductible to him nor income to her on either return. In a 2025 judgment, at 2025 state rates, his California tax would have fallen about $5,022 and hers risen about $4,912: a $110 net difference.

Still married at the end of 2026, they choose joint or separate returns. Filing separately, community wages through March 15 (about $52,712 of his, $14,192 of hers) split in half, so he reports about $240,740 and she about $89,260. Joint filing may cost less but makes each liable for the whole bill.

If she keeps the house and sells in 2029 as a single filer, $200,000 of the $450,000 gain is taxable. If both stay on title and the judgment grants her occupancy until sale, each excludes a $225,000 share.

If the S corporation is worth $600,000 with $100,000 of stock basis, an even split gives her $300,000 of full-basis assets while he holds $500,000 of untaxed gain: about $150,000 of deferred tax at an assumed 30 percent combined rate, which his side will want counted and hers, citing Fonstein, will resist.

Why bring a forensic accountant into a California divorce?

Because characterization lives in the bank records. See v. See (1966) 64 Cal.2d 778 presumes property bought during marriage is community and puts the record-keeping burden on the spouse who commingles, and In re Marriage of Mix (1975) 14 Cal.3d 604 accepted separate funds traced through testimony and a reconstructed schedule. Growth in a premarital business is apportioned under Pereira v. Pereira (1909) 156 Cal. 1 or Van Camp v. Van Camp (1921) 53 Cal.App. 17, as Beam v. Bank of America (1971) 6 Cal.3d 12 explains.

I put tax basis on the marital balance sheet beside value, since equal values with unequal basis are not equal after tax. Trust money raises the same tracing issues (see trusts in a California divorce).

ItemFederal ruleCalifornia ruleWhere it shows up
Support, instrument signed 2019 to 2025Not deductible or taxableDeductible and taxableSchedule CA (540), lines 2a and 19a
Support, instrument signed 2026 or laterNot deductible or taxableSame (SB 711)Nowhere
Child supportNot deductible or taxableSameNowhere
§ 1041 transfersNo gain; carryover basisSame; no reassessment (§ 63)Form 8949 on later sale
Separation-year income§ 66 only if apart all yearFam. Code § 771 splitForm 8958; matching status
Innocent spouse relief§ 6015, Form 8857§ 18533, FTB 705; court revision (§ 19006)Separate requests
QDRO vs. IRAQDRO cash skips 10%QDRO cash skips 2.5%FTB 3805P

Frequently Asked Questions

My California divorce judgment was entered in 2024. Do I still deduct spousal support on my state return?

Yes. Instruments signed from 2019 through 2025 keep the California deduction through Schedule CA (540). That changes only if a later modification expressly adopts the new rules.

Is child support taxable in California?

No. Neither the IRS nor the FTB taxes it or allows the payor a deduction. Under older instruments, spousal support that drops when a child turns 18 can be treated as child support.

Can the family court make my ex pay our old joint tax debt?

The order binds your ex but not the IRS. For California tax, an order under Fam. Code § 2628 and R&TC § 19006 can bind the FTB if it meets the statute’s limits.

Do I pay a penalty on cash from my ex’s 401(k) under a QDRO?

Not the 10 percent federal or 2.5 percent California additional tax, though income tax applies. Roll it to an IRA and withdraw before 59½, and both additional taxes apply.

Should we file jointly for the year we separated?

It may save tax, but each spouse becomes liable for the whole bill. Separate returns require splitting community income earned before the date of separation, and California follows your federal filing status.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm supports family law counsel on the tax side of California dissolutions, including innocent spouse disputes through its tax defense practice, home sale planning through real estate tax strategy, and business basis and valuation through business sale tax structuring. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Tax Court, with forensic accounting experience in dissolution matters.

If your settlement is still being negotiated, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before the judgment is signed.