North Star Law Firm logoNorth Star Law Firm
☰

Compete and Lose the Payout? California Treats Employees and Owners Differently

The Delta King and other riverboats docked along the Old Sacramento waterfront on the Sacramento River, California

You are a physician leaving a medical group in Sacramento. Your shareholder agreement pays half your accounts receivable when you leave, but only if you stay 15 miles away. You signed a Roseville lease. Is that money gone?

A Texas appeals court said yes to that in August 2026. In California the answer depends on whether you signed as an employee, an owner, or both. An employee’s “compete and lose the money” clause is void here. An owner who sold real goodwill can be charged a price for competing.

Can a California employer take back a bonus or pension because you joined a competitor?

Generally, no. Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600(a) voids every contract that restrains anyone from a lawful profession, trade, or business, except as the chapter allows. AB 1076 added subdivision (b), effective January 1, 2024, directing a broad reading under Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937, which voided even a narrow employee noncompete.

The form of the clause does not matter. In Chamberlain v. Augustine (1916) 172 Cal. 285, a promise to pay $5,000 for entering a similar business was void because the payment deterred competition. Then Muggill v. Reuben H. Donnelley Corp. (1965) 62 Cal.2d 239 applied the same logic to a retiree whose pension was cut off when he went to work for a competitor. The plan was part of his employment contract, so the forfeiture clause was void and the judgment against him was reversed.

Section 16600.1 required notices by February 14, 2024 telling workers their noncompetes were void. Section 16600.5 (SB 699) makes a void clause unenforceable wherever and whenever it was signed, makes trying to enforce one a civil violation, and gives the worker a suit for an injunction, damages, and attorney’s fees.

When can a California business owner be charged a price for competing?

Three exceptions cover owners. Section 16601 lets someone who sells a business’s goodwill, or all of an ownership interest, agree with the buyer not to compete in a specified area where the business operated. Section 16602 does the same for a partner on dissolution or dissociation, and section 16602.5 for an LLC member when the company dissolves or the member’s interest ends.

Partners have the most room. Farthing v. San Mateo Clinic (1956) 143 Cal.App.2d 385 upheld a medical partnership clause that stopped paying a retiring partner his share of receivables once he opened an office in San Mateo. Howard v. Babcock (1993) 6 Cal.4th 409, following Haight, Brown & Bonesteel v. Superior Court (1991) 234 Cal.App.3d 963, said these agreements “place a price on competition” and allowed law partners “a reasonable toll” on a departing partner who competes.

Shareholders have less room, and most medical groups are corporations. Hill Medical Corp. v. Wycoff (2001) 86 Cal.App.4th 895 involved a radiologist who was both employee and 7 percent shareholder. On leaving he had to sell his shares back at net book value (about $217,000), with no goodwill component. The court refused to apply § 16601 or rewrite the covenant. There must be “a clear indication” that the parties valued goodwill as part of the price, and a sale back to the corporation is not enough. Relevant facts include the size of the stake and whether the price approached fair market value.

Would the Texas cardiology practice agreement hold up in California?

In Afzal v. Ramineni, No. 09-25-00138-CV (Tex. App. Beaumont Aug. 6, 2026) (mem. op.), a cardiologist was an employee and 20 percent shareholder; new shareholders paid a $180,000 buy in. On departure his shares were repurchased at an agreed $1.00 per share, and he got 50 percent of his receivables only if he practiced outside a 20 mile radius. He paid $100,000 to buy out a separate employment noncompete, practiced across the street, then sued for $428,828.43. The court called the clause a forfeiture provision, not a covenant not to compete, and ruled that he recover nothing. A petition for review was reportedly filed.

In California, the employment noncompete fails first. A $100,000 price to compete, imposed on an employee, is the Chamberlain pattern. On my reading he would have a claim to recover that payment as actual damages under § 16600.5(e).

The receivables clause is harder. As an owner, he falls under § 16601 only if goodwill was sold, and a $1.00 per share price is the opposite of a goodwill price, weaker than the book value that failed in Hill Medical. His 20 percent stake is more substantial, and the practice could call the receivables payment the real price, yet it was measured by work he had already done. Without § 16601, the condition is a void restraint, and in Muggill the forfeiture itself was set aside, not just the bar on competing. The practice could owe the money whether or not he competed. I found no published California case applying Hill Medical to a conditional payment rather than an express covenant, so that outcome is likely, not certain.

A Texas choice of law or forum clause would not fix this for a doctor who primarily lives and works in California. Cal. Lab. Code § 925 makes such a clause voidable by the employee unless the employee was individually represented by counsel in negotiating those terms, which physician owners often are. Section 16600.5(a) and (b) still reach a void clause signed elsewhere, and Application Group, Inc. v. Hunter Group, Inc. (1998) 61 Cal.App.4th 881 refused to apply a Maryland choice of law clause against California policy.

What would this mean for a Sacramento physician opening in Roseville?

Illustrative example. Anjali bought 20 percent of a medical corporation in Sacramento’s Natomas area for $150,000 and works for it under an employment agreement. The shareholder agreement pays book value for her shares when she leaves, plus 50 percent of her receivables ($380,000) if she does not practice within 15 miles for two years. She opens an office in Roseville, about 12 miles away.

The practice will argue the owner side. Under Hill Medical, book value cuts against it unless the books carry goodwill or the record shows the $150,000 buy in and the $380,000 were priced as goodwill. Her 20 percent stake helps the practice. If a court finds no goodwill sale, the 15 mile condition is void and she has a strong claim to the $380,000. If it finds one, she likely forfeits. Board minutes and appraisals will decide it.

Does ERISA or the tax code change the answer?

ERISA can. Smith v. CMTA-IAM Pension Trust, 654 F.2d 650 (9th Cir. 1981), noted that ERISA superseded state law relating to plans as of January 1, 1975, and Lojek v. Thomas, 716 F.2d 675 (9th Cir. 1983), held that ERISA preempted state law and upheld a law firm plan’s competition forfeiture, but only for benefits above ERISA’s minimum vesting floor. A receivables payment like the one in Afzal is not an ERISA plan benefit, so § 16600 still governs it.

The tax point is a question for the plan’s tax adviser. Under Treas. Reg. § 1.83-3(c)(2), even “an enforceable requirement” to return property for joining a competitor ordinarily is not a substantial risk of forfeiture. Under Treas. Reg. § 1.409A-1(d)(1), an amount is not at substantial risk merely because it is conditioned on refraining from services. If California also voids the condition, the “unvested” label that won in Texas may not defer tax, and 409A timing rules may already apply.

What can a California practice put in its agreements instead?

Tie vesting to time served, not to where someone practices afterward; forfeiting an unearned award for leaving early does not restrain competing. AB 692 now limits repayment terms, as I covered in an earlier post on California’s stay or pay law. For owners, price goodwill in a documented valuation so § 16601 applies, or use § 16602 or § 16602.5 with a reasonable toll.

Patient lists and payer pricing can be protected as trade secrets under the Uniform Trade Secrets Act (Cal. Civ. Code § 3426.1) if the practice keeps them secret. In my view, a clause barring a departing employee from soliciting coworkers is largely unenforceable in California after recent appellate decisions and the 2024 amendments, so I do not rely on one.

Who is leavingCan the agreement make competing cost money?AuthorityDrafting condition that matters
EmployeeNo, and trying is a civil violation§§ 16600, 16600.5; MuggillNone; vest by time served instead
Partner leaving a partnershipYes, if reasonable§ 16602; Howard; FarthingDissolution or dissociation; specified area; reasonable toll
LLC memberYes, on the statute’s terms§ 16602.5Dissolution or end of interest; specified area
Shareholder selling all sharesOnly if goodwill is really sold§ 16601; Hill MedicalSubstantial stake; price that values goodwill
ERISA plan participantOften yes, above the vesting floorERISA preemption; LojekPlan must meet minimum vesting

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a forfeiture for competition clause a noncompete in California?

For employees, it is treated as a restraint. The California Supreme Court voided a pension forfeiture for working for a competitor in 1965. An unvested label does not change that.

Does selling my shares back to my medical group let it enforce a noncompete?

Not automatically. California courts look for a clear indication that the price included goodwill. A book value or nominal repurchase price usually fails that test.

Can my employer sue me in Texas under Texas law if I work in California?

If you primarily live and work in California, Labor Code section 925 lets you void a clause requiring an out of state forum or law. The exception is when you had your own lawyer negotiate those terms.

Can a California partnership make a departing partner pay for competing?

Yes, within limits. Business and Professions Code section 16602 allows agreements on dissolution or dissociation, and the toll must be reasonable. For law partners, an outright ban is per se unreasonable.

What can I recover if my employer tries to enforce a void noncompete?

Section 16600.5 allows a suit for an injunction, actual damages, or both. A prevailing employee also recovers reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm drafts shareholder and operating agreements with departure terms that fit California law, reviews physician agreements through contract drafting and review, and prices goodwill when an exit is really a sale through buying and selling a business. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA.

To review a departure clause or buyout, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation.