North Star Law Firm logoNorth Star Law Firm
☰

California FTB Notice After an IRS 1099-K Change: Barraza, Proof, and Where to Fight

The stepped, pyramid shaped Ziggurat state office building behind a row of evergreens along the Sacramento River in California

Written by

in

The Franchise Tax Board letter concerns a year you thought was closed. It says your California income was too low because the IRS added the full PayPal or eBay Form 1099-K. You paid for that inventory. The platform kept its fees. The notice mentions neither.

That was the setup in Appeal of G. Barraza, Case No. 231214989, which OTA, California’s Office of Tax Appeals, decided on April 25, 2025. It shows what California accepts as proof. My read goes further than “keep records”: much of this fight belonged at the IRS.

Why does the FTB send a notice years after the IRS changed my return?

The IRS shares adjustments; in the precedential Appeal of Gorin, 2020-OTA-018P, the FTB assessed from CP2000 data it received under IRC § 6103(d). Rev. & Tax. Code § 18622(a) also requires you to report a federal change within six months of the final federal determination and “concede the accuracy of the determination or state wherein it is erroneous.” The clock starts when the IRS assesses (§ 18622(d)).

The FTB normally has four years from filing (§ 19057(a)). If you or the IRS report the change within six months, it gets two years from the report or the four years, whichever is later (§ 19059(a)). A late report gives four years from notice (§ 19060(b)). With no report, the notice “may be mailed to the taxpayer at any time” (§ 19060(a)).

What did the Office of Tax Appeals actually decide in Barraza?

Mr. Barraza, an eBay seller, left a $100,638 PayPal Form 1099-K off his 2018 returns. The FTB’s December 28, 2022 notice sought $8,120 plus interest. He then petitioned the Tax Court, which dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, and the IRS reassessed in June 2023. His amended federal return changed nothing. The FTB affirmed in November 2023.

On appeal he claimed $97,264.26 of offsets. He had help by then: law students from the Tax Appeals Assistance Program (TAAP) filed his reply briefs. The panel allowed one item, $4,002.77 of eBay fees backed by eBay’s invoices, and rejected cost of goods sold, refunds, other fees and phone charges. The opinion is nonprecedential (2025-OTA-663).

One detail explains the refund ruling. His eBay invoices showed $125,561.80 of sales, more than the 1099-K. Either sales were missing from the form or PayPal had already netted refunds, and with no sales invoices the panel could not tell which.

What are my deadlines after an FTB Notice of Proposed Assessment?

Sixty days. A written protest is due within 60 days after mailing (§ 19041(a)), and filing by the date printed on the notice is timely (§ 19041(b)). Send records with it, not promises.

A Notice of Action becomes final 30 days after mailing unless you appeal to OTA (§ 19045(a); Gov. Code § 15672). A personal income tax appeal under $5,000, penalties included, may elect a single judge whose decision is not precedential (Gov. Code § 15676.2).

After an OTA opinion, rehearing must be sought within 30 days (§ 19048), and new evidence counts only if you could not reasonably have produced it earlier (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 30604(a)(3)). Then you pay, claim a refund, and sue (§ 19382). Interest runs throughout (§ 19101); the accuracy penalty tracks IRC § 6662 (§ 19164). An unpayable balance points to an installment agreement or offer in compromise.

Holding an FTB Notice of Proposed Assessment built on an IRS 1099-K change? The 60 day protest clock runs from the mailing date, and what you file now shapes the rest.

Should I fight the IRS adjustment instead of the FTB notice?

Often, yes. The FTB’s number rides on the federal number. Mr. Barraza’s Notice of Action issued after he had not shown the IRS reduced its assessment, so proving the expenses federally would have moved both.

The easiest moment is the CP2000, which the IRS calls a proposal, not a bill, answerable with documents by the date on the notice. After that, a notice of deficiency allows 90 days to petition the Tax Court (IRC § 6213(a)); a petition the court cannot hear is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, as his was, though the opinion does not say why (see my post on a missed Tax Court deadline).

That dismissal does not lock the federal door. Audit reconsideration (IRS Publication 3598; IRM 4.13.1) reopens an unpaid assessment when you identify the disputed adjustments and bring information the IRS never considered (IRM 4.13.1.2.1). It covers CP2000 assessments (IRM 4.13.1.3.2), and a case the Tax Court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction is worked this way when new information arrives (IRM 4.13.1.4.5). If you already paid, Publication 3598 requires a formal claim instead.

When the IRS abates, send the FTB the letter and a transcript. If you paid California, a refund claim is due within two years of the final federal determination (§ 19311(a)(1)); FTB Publication 1008 covers protective claims. Fight at the FTB or OTA when the federal route is closed or the issue is California only.

What records prove that a 1099-K overstates my income?

A deficiency based on a federal adjustment is presumed correct, and “unsupported assertions are not sufficient” (Gorin, citing Appeal of Brockett, 86-SBE-109, and Appeal of Magidow, 82-SBE-274). The appellant must prove error by a preponderance of the evidence (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 30219).

A 1099-K reports gross payments, not profit. For a reseller, gross income is sales less cost of goods sold (Treas. Reg. § 1.61-3(a)), but the cost must be proved, and fees and refunds must tie to the same account and year. What would have worked for Mr. Barraza: downloaded eBay and PayPal transaction histories, unredacted bank statements, and supplier invoices matched to sales. A spreadsheet only summarizes those.

Cohan v. Commissioner, 39 F.2d 540 (2d Cir. 1930), lets a fact finder approximate an expense clearly incurred, and OTA applies it, but the Ninth Circuit requires “a credible evidentiary basis,” and unquantified income defeats an estimate (Norgaard v. Commissioner, 939 F.2d 874 (9th Cir. 1991)). With his sales uncertain, OTA estimated nothing.

Selling your own used things at a loss is not income, yet a 1099-K still issues past the threshold, which Pub. L. 119-21, § 70432 set at more than $20,000 and more than 200 transactions, retroactively (IRC § 6050W(e)). I looked for a lower California threshold for sellers and found none; the FTB follows the federal rule back to 2022, keeping $600 only for app based drivers.

How would an FTB notice play out for a Fontana sneaker reseller?

Illustrative example. Devon resells sneakers on eBay from Fontana. He left a 2022 Form 1099-K for $48,300 (about 260 sales) off his return. The IRS assessed it all in March 2025; Devon never told the FTB. His records show $31,000 of inventory cost, $6,100 of fees, and $3,400 of refunds inside the 1099-K gross: net profit of $7,800.

Assume Devon is single with $52,000 of wages, so his 2022 California taxable income was $46,798 after the $5,202 standard deduction, taxed at $1,472 under the 2022 tax table. Adding $48,300 makes it $95,098 and $5,598, an increase of $4,126, pushing his top rate from 6 to 9.3 percent. Adding $7,800 makes it $54,598 and $1,983, an increase of $511. Self employment tax is federal only.

The calendar: his six months to report ran out in September 2025, so under § 19060(a) the FTB has no deadline for 2022. If the notice is mailed October 9, 2026, his protest is due December 8, 2026, with the eBay and PayPal histories and supplier invoices attached. While the federal balance is unpaid, he asks the IRS for audit reconsideration and says so in the protest. A Notice of Action would give him 30 days to appeal, likely within the single judge limit.

StageDeadlineWhat you fileWhat proof helps
IRS CP2000Reply by the date on the noticeResponse form and explanationPlatform sales history, purchase invoices, refund records
IRS audit reconsiderationTax must be unpaid (if paid, a formal claim)Letter, Form 12661, new documentsInformation the IRS never considered
FTB Notice of Proposed Assessment60 days from mailing (§ 19041)Written protestSame records, plus any IRS abatement
FTB Notice of Action30 days from mailing (§ 19045)Appeal to OTAA complete written record
OTA appealBriefing set by OTA; rehearing within 30 days (§ 19048)Briefs and exhibitsContemporaneous documents, not rebuilt spreadsheets
After OTAPay, claim refund, then sue (§ 19382)Refund claim, then superior court complaintIf the IRS later reduces, a claim within two years (§ 19311)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the FTB assess a tax year that is more than four years old?

Yes, when an IRS change is involved. If nobody reported the change to California, section 19060(a) allows a notice at any time; a late report gives the FTB four years from the report.

Is the amount on a Form 1099-K the same as my taxable income?

No. It reports gross payments processed. A reseller’s gross income is sales less cost of goods sold, but you must prove that cost, and any fees and refunds, with records from the same account and year.

Will the FTB drop its assessment if the IRS reduces my federal tax?

Generally it follows the revised federal figure once you send the IRS abatement letter and transcript. If you already paid California, file a refund claim within two years of the final federal determination.

Can a spreadsheet prove my expenses in an OTA appeal?

Only as a summary of documents you also produce. In Barraza, OTA rejected a workbook it could not check against contemporaneous records and allowed only fees shown on eBay’s own invoices.

Is there free help for an Office of Tax Appeals case?

Possibly. OTA’s taxpayer resources describe a Tax Appeals Assistance Program that may provide free representation by supervised law students when less than $30,000 is in dispute.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm handles FTB protests and IRS reconsideration requests through its tax defense practice, represents clients in Tax Court and Office of Tax Appeals cases, and arranges installment agreements for remaining balances. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Tax Court.

If an FTB notice followed an IRS change to your return, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation.