The email reaches the board chair on a Tuesday: the giving platform your charity relies on has paused payouts because the organization is “not in good standing.” Nobody knows which agency it means.
California has three possible culprits, sometimes four, each with its own cure, and a new statute changes only part of this.
Why would an online giving platform stop paying a California charity?
Since AB 488 (Stats. 2021, ch. 591), Gov. Code § 12599.9(d)(2) has let a platform “receive, control, or distribute funds from donations” only for charities in good standing, meaning no exemption revoked by the IRS or the Franchise Tax Board and no Attorney General bar. The Attorney General’s platform regulations (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, §§ 314 to 323) apply the same test in § 316(a).
Then there is money already given: under § 320(a)(3), within 30 days after finding a recipient ineligible, the platform writes to donors asking them to recommend another charity, and if they stay silent it picks one. A two-month block can move donations for good.
What does AB 2221 change for blocked charities, and when?
AB 2221 became Chapter 590 of the Statutes of 2026 on September 27, 2026. With no urgency clause, it takes effect January 1, 2027 (Cal. Const. art. IV, § 8(c)(1)).
The IRS drops out. Amended § 12599.9(a)(3) looks only to revocation “by the Franchise Tax Board” and to an Attorney General bar “on the basis of a cease and desist order, delinquency, suspension, or revocation” under new § 12599.12. FTB revocation still blocks you.
Delinquency now requires warning. Section 12599.12(b) calls for a written notice, 60 days, a second notice and 60 more days before a third notice can declare a registration delinquent; suspension or revocation needs an administrative action under Cal. Code Regs. tit. 11, § 336 and following. From January 1, 2028, a catch-up filing by an expired or delinquent registrant that sits unprocessed for 15 calendar days is deemed in good standing, though not for a suspended or revoked one.
The platform must still segregate donations and may not “divert or otherwise misuse” them (§ 12599.9(h)(1)), but it may promptly send them to an alternate charity it has disclosed or, for some solicitation types, refund gifts of $10 or less. Nothing in the chaptered text makes it wait while a charity cures.
Has a giving platform frozen your charity’s donations, or did an FTB or IRS revocation notice just arrive? Donors can be asked to pick another charity within weeks of an ineligibility finding, so start the cure now.
How does a charity clear a Delinquent status with the Attorney General’s Registry?
In the Registry’s status definitions, “Registered” replaced the old “Current” label; Delinquent, Suspended, Revoked and Expired lack good standing. Reports under Gov. Code § 12586 are due four months and 15 days after year end: Form RRF-1 plus the Form 990 or 990-EZ, or Form CT-TR-1 for a 990-N filer (renewal page). The fee is $25 under $50,000 of revenue. Late fees are $25 for each month or part of one (§ 12586.1), not payable from charitable assets. Section 12591.1(c) allows penalties up to $1,000 per act or omission.
To cure, file every missing year online and pay. Move fast: under Rev. & Tax. Code § 23703 the Attorney General can refer you to the FTB, which revokes the state exemption if you have not caught up 120 days after its notice of intent.
Why is an FTB revocation the hardest block to clear?
Small charities file Form 199, or the FTB 199N e-Postcard if gross receipts are normally $50,000 or less. Per FTB Pub. 1068, three missed 199Ns revoke the exemption as of the third due date, and other missed returns or payments can lead to suspension (§ 23775) or revocation (§ 23777).
This is the block that bites. A corporation without an exemption files Form 100 and owes at least the $800 minimum franchise tax (§ 23153) each year. The FTB 3500 booklet says the FTB “may grant tax-exempt status retroactively” for periods the charity proves it qualified. Section 23778 requires a new application plus the missing returns and payments behind the revocation, and a charity the FTB revoked cannot use the short Form 3500A.
Suspension is worse. Contracts made while suspended under § 23301, 23301.5 or 23775 are “voidable at the request of any party to the contract other than the taxpayer” (§ 23304.1), and Pub. 1068 warns a suspended corporation cannot sue or defend itself. That reaches the warehouse lease and the county grant. The Secretary of State is the fourth agency to check: Form SI-100 is due every two years (Corp. Code § 6210), and § 5008.6 allows suspension 60 days after notice of a missed one, which the FTB lists among causes of revocation.
How does a charity get its 501(c)(3) status back after an IRS auto-revocation?
Under IRC § 6033(j)(1), three straight years without a 990-series return or 990-N revokes exemption “on and after the date set by the Secretary for the filing of the third annual return or notice.” The charity then falls outside § 170(c)(2), and the IRS says it “is not eligible to receive tax-deductible contributions.”
Under Rev. Proc. 2014-11, a first-time revokee that could have filed the 990-EZ or 990-N each year gets streamlined retroactive reinstatement by applying within 15 months of the later of the revocation letter or its listing, with paper 990-EZs marked “Retroactive Reinstatement” and no reasonable cause statement. Others need reasonable cause for retroactive relief. The user fee is $600 for Form 1023 and $275 for the 1023-EZ, which Rev. Proc. 2014-40 closes to charities with gross receipts over $50,000 in any of the past three years.
How would a San Bernardino food pantry dig out?
An illustrative case: Ruben chairs a San Bernardino food pantry, a calendar-year nonprofit public benefit corporation with 501(c)(3) status since 2019. Online campaigns lifted it to about $180,000 in 2025, 40 percent through platforms. In October 2026 payouts stop. The FTB revoked in 2025 after no 199Ns for 2022 through 2024, the Registry shows Delinquent for missing 2022 and 2023 RRF-1s, and the IRS auto-revoked in May 2026 for 2023 through 2025.
A bizfile search confirms the SI-100 ($20, five days or less online, if one is due). The two RRF-1s go in with CT-TR-1s and $25 fees; filed in mid-November 2026, full late fees would be 43 and 31 months, about $1,850, paid from a non-charitable source.
The pantry fits the streamlined route (990-Ns would have sufficed for 2023 and 2024, a 990-EZ for 2025), but its 2025 receipts rule out the 1023-EZ, so it files Form 1023 ($600) with three paper 990-EZs. It also files the three 199Ns and an FTB 3500 asking for exemption back to the revocation date. Until the FTB agrees, expect roughly $1,600 of minimum tax for 2025 and 2026, plus penalties. I would budget months at both agencies.
The $14,000 at the platform is the hard part. If the ineligibility finding came in early October, donor letters may already be out. Ruben should call this week, ask when it made the finding and whether donors were contacted, and send proof of each filing.
Would AB 2221 have helped in 2027? Partly. The IRS revocation would stop counting, and from 2028 his Registry catch-up would be deemed good after 15 unprocessed days, but the FTB revocation would still block every payout.
What calendar and self-audit keep a California charity in good standing?
Small charities slip because nobody owns the calendar. For a December 31 year, May 15 carries the federal return (IRC § 6072(e)), Form 199 or 199N, and the RRF-1; a June 30 year moves all three to November 15. The Registry honors IRS extensions and Form 199 gets six months; the 199N gets none. The SI-100 comes every other year, in the month the articles were filed or the five before. I tell boards to name one officer per line.
Then audit yourself. The IRS FY2026 TE/GE program letter picks exams with “data analytics and referrals,” and the FY2027 letter names organizations “operating outside of exempt purposes” and unrelated business income. Even a 990-EZ filer should answer the Form 990 Part VI governance questions, starting with a written conflict of interest policy. Test director deals against the Corp. Code § 5233 safe harbor, run the one-third public support test, and look for unrelated income. My post on section 5236 insider loans covers one such trap.
| Agency | What puts you out | How to check | How to cure | Typical time | AB 2221 (2027) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AG Registry | Missing RRF-1; unpaid fees | Registry Search Tool | File online; fees plus $25 a month late | No published time | Three notices first; 15-day rule from 2028 |
| FTB | Missed 199 or 199N; unpaid tax; AG referral | Entity Status Letter | Missing returns plus FTB 3500 | Several months | Still blocks |
| IRS | Three missed annual filings | Tax Exempt Organization Search | Form 1023 or 1023-EZ | Months; 15-month window | No longer blocks |
| Secretary of State | Missed biennial SI-100 | bizfile search | SI-100, $20 | Five days or less | Not listed; can lead to FTB trouble |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does AB 2221 take effect right away?
No. It takes effect January 1, 2027. The 15-day deemed good standing rule waits until January 1, 2028.
Can a platform send our donations to a different charity?
Yes. Today’s regulations have it ask donors for an alternate and choose one itself if they do not answer. From 2027 it may use an alternate it has disclosed.
Are gifts deductible while the IRS revocation stands?
The IRS says an auto-revoked 501(c)(3) cannot receive deductible contributions. Retroactive reinstatement restores status from the revocation date, which is why the 15-month window matters.
Can we pay Registry late fees out of donations?
No. The Attorney General says charitable assets cannot pay late fees. Use a non-charitable source and note it in the minutes.
Does fixing the IRS revocation fix the FTB revocation?
No. The FTB needs its own Form 3500 and missing returns. File both applications together.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm sets up charity governance and filing calendars through its entity formation work, catches up missing returns through its unfiled returns practice, and reviews leases and grants exposed by a suspension through contract review. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA.
If a platform has frozen your donations, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before your donors are redirected.
