North Star Law Firm logoNorth Star Law Firm
☰

Paying One Creditor First in California: Civil Code 3432, the UVTA and Preferences

The neon sign of the Willo Steakhouse, a roadside restaurant in California, against a pale sky.

Written by

in

At a Temecula restaurant or Corona print shop, the account holds less than the bills. The landlord has called twice, a merchant cash advance debits every weekday, your brother wants his loan back, and the payroll tax deposit is late.

California lets you choose who gets paid, but not every choice sticks, and the payment that both stays put and protects you personally is the one owners skip. This is general information, not advice to pay or skip any creditor.

Is it legal in California to pay one creditor and not the others?

Yes. Cal. Civ. Code § 3432, on the books since 1872, says: “A debtor may pay one creditor in preference to another, or may give to one creditor security for the payment of his demand in preference to another.” The idea is older. In Clark v. White, 37 U.S. (12 Pet.) 178 (1838), the Supreme Court refused to unwind a debtor’s partial payments, noting his bank debts were “secured by the endorsements of friends.” Paying a debt someone guaranteed for you is what bankruptcy law now watches.

The state-law limit is California’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act (UVTA). A creditor can undo transfers made with “actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud” under § 3439.04(a)(1), weighing eleven factors, starting with transfers to insiders. Without intent, § 3439.05(a) reaches an insolvent debtor’s transfers for less than “reasonably equivalent value.” Paying a real bill answers that: § 3439.03 counts value as given when “an antecedent debt is secured or satisfied.”

The uniform act also voids an insolvent debtor’s repayment of an insider who knew, or should have known, of the insolvency. California skipped that subsection: § 3439.05 holds only the constructive fraud rule and a burden-of-proof sentence, and § 3439.01 never defines “insider.” Outside bankruptcy, a creditor attacking your brother’s repayment must prove actual intent, within four years (or one year after discovery), never past seven (§ 3439.09).

Do the owners of an insolvent California company owe creditors equal treatment?

Not generally. Berg & Berg Enterprises, LLC v. Boyle, 178 Cal. App. 4th 1020 (2009), found “no broad, paramount fiduciary duty” to creditors arising from insolvency alone. The trust fund doctrine still bars actions that “divert, dissipate, or unduly risk corporate assets,” which “would include acts that involve self-dealing or the preferential treatment of creditors.”

The older cases behind it involved directors paying themselves or their own companies. My read: choosing the produce supplier over the linen service is fine; repaying the owner’s own loan first is the target. Berg involved a corporation; I would not expect LLC managers to fare better.

How far back can a bankruptcy trustee take back payments to creditors?

Ninety days, or one year for insiders. Under 11 U.S.C. § 547(b), a trustee recovers an insolvent debtor’s payment on an old debt that gave the creditor more than Chapter 7 would. Insolvency is presumed for the last 90 days (§ 547(f)). Insiders include officers, persons in control and their relatives (§ 101(31)(B)), so the owner’s brother counts. No bad intent is needed.

The defenses sit in § 547(c). Cash on delivery is a contemporaneous exchange. Ordinary-course payments are protected; the Ninth Circuit asks whether they were “routine,” judged first by how the two parties dealt with each other (In re Ahaza Systems, Inc., 482 F.3d 1118 (9th Cir. 2007), applying the pre-2005 text). Later shipments count as new value. In a business case, transfers to one creditor under $8,575 in total, the floor since the April 1, 2025 adjustment, are untouchable (§ 547(c)(9)).

Guaranties change the math. Paying a landlord or lender you guaranteed benefits you, an insider. For payments between day 91 and one year, § 547(i) and § 550(c) protect the outside creditor, but § 550(a)(1) lets the trustee recover from “the entity for whose benefit such transfer was made.” That is you.

Deciding which bills your California business pays this month? Each payment starts a 90-day or one-year clock, and the order decides what a trustee recovers and what stays with you.

Why are withheld payroll taxes the safest debt to pay first?

The money was never the company’s. Withheld income tax and employee FICA are “a special fund in trust for the United States” (26 U.S.C. § 7501(a)), and Begier v. IRS, 496 U.S. 53 (1990), held that paying them from general accounts transfers no property of the debtor, so the payments “cannot be avoided as preferences.” California’s withholding statute uses the same trust language (Unemp. Ins. Code § 13070(b)), so I expect the same result for EDD withholding, though Begier read only the federal one.

Those dollars also follow the owner home. Anyone responsible who “willfully fails” to pay them over owes an equal penalty (26 U.S.C. § 6672(a)). The Ninth Circuit calls willfulness a “voluntary, conscious and intentional act to prefer other creditors over the United States,” and meeting payroll does not excuse it (Phillips v. United States, 73 F.3d 939 (9th Cir. 1996)). EDD assesses the person in charge under Unemp. Ins. Code § 1735. The withholding-based debts survive a personal discharge (11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(1)(A), with § 507(a)(8)(C)).

Two cautions. Employer FICA is not trust money, and the IRS applies undesignated partial payments to non-trust taxes first, so designate in writing (IRS CCA 202129007). Sales tax is murkier. California imposes it on the retailer (Rev. & Tax. Code § 6051), and In re George, 95 B.R. 718 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 1989), saw it as closer to a retailer’s tax than a trust-fund tax. The personal exposure is clear: after the business closes, Rev. & Tax. Code § 6829 reaches a responsible person who willfully failed to pay, and George held that liability nondischargeable.

What happens if a Murrieta restaurant owner pays the loudest creditors first?

Illustrative facts: Marisol’s LLC owns two Murrieta restaurants. In mid-October 2026 it has $70,000 and owes $60,000 in payroll taxes ($38,000 trust-fund withholding), $40,000 in back rent she guaranteed, $35,000 to her brother, and $50,000 to vendors. An MCA’s 21 daily debits of $900 from October 15 to November 12 take $18,900, leaving $51,100.

Version one follows the noise: $40,000 to the landlord and $11,100 to her brother on October 15. The LLC files Chapter 7 in the Central District of California, Riverside Division, on January 12, 2027, 89 days later. The trustee can pursue the $40,000 from the landlord or, since it shrank her guaranty, from her; a landlord that repays gets its claim back under § 502(h) and, under most guaranty forms, her guaranty too. The MCA defends its $18,900 as ordinary course or a true sale. The brother returns $11,100. The $38,000 is unpaid, so § 6672 and § 1735 assessments follow her.

Version two sends $38,000, designated to the withheld federal and EDD amounts, and spends $13,100 on COD food and the closing payroll. Begier keeps the trustee off the $38,000, and COD purchases are contemporaneous exchanges. Her personal exposure falls by $38,000; the guaranty stays either way.

Move the filing to September 2027. Past 90 days, § 550(c) shields the landlord, but Marisol still answers for the guaranty benefit and her brother for $11,100, with insolvency proved, not presumed. Under $8,575 total, § 547(c)(9) would have protected him. After October 15, 2027, only a four-year UVTA intent claim, brought through § 544(b), could reach him.

Does a trustee’s preference demand letter mean I did something wrong?

No. A preference claim needs no fraud or knowledge; it pools recent payments so creditors share. Since a 2019 amendment, the trustee must act “based on reasonable due diligence” and weigh known defenses, though the recipient still proves them (§ 547(g)). Invoices and payment history answer most letters, which is where our preference clawback defense work starts. Whether an MCA was really a loan is a separate question, covered in my post on Kossoff.

PayeeCiv. Code § 3432UVTA riskPreference riskEffect on the owner
Trust-fund payroll and sales taxesAllowedLowNone for withholding; employer share and sales tax, 90 daysCuts § 6672, § 1735 and § 6829 exposure
Employee wagesAllowedLow90 days; current payroll usually ordinary courseWage claims can reach owners (Lab. Code § 558.1)
LandlordAllowedLow90 days; ordinary course, new valueTrustee can sue the guarantor for a year
Bank or SBA loan with guarantyAllowedLow90 days; regular installments may be ordinary courseSame as landlord
Merchant cash advanceAllowedLow90 days; true sale, ordinary courseOften guaranteed
Family or owner loanAllowed, but trust fund doctrineInsider is a badge of intentOne year; insolvency proved after day 90Relative is sued
Ordinary vendorsAllowedLow90 days; ordinary course, COD, new valueNone unless guaranteed
Owner’s salaryAllowed if reasonableExcess pay lacks equivalent valueBack pay, one year; excess pay, two years (§ 548)Trustee sues owner

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my California business pay vendors and let the IRS wait?

Section 3432 allows it, but the withheld portion becomes your personal problem. The Ninth Circuit treats knowingly paying others first as willful under section 6672.

Does California have an insider preference rule outside bankruptcy?

No. California’s section 3439.05 omits the uniform act’s insider subsection, so a creditor must prove actual intent. Bankruptcy adds the one-year insider window.

Can I repay my own loan to the company before it closes?

It is the riskiest payment here. A trustee can recover it for a year, and it is the self-preference the trust fund doctrine targets.

What is the smallest payment a trustee can recover in a business bankruptcy?

Transfers to one creditor must total at least $8,575, the section 547(c)(9) figure since April 1, 2025. It next adjusts April 1, 2028.

If the trustee recovers rent the company paid, am I liable on my guaranty again?

Usually. The landlord’s claim returns under section 502(h), and most guaranties revive when a payment is returned. The trustee may also sue you directly.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm helps California owners sequence payments, answers trustee demands through its preference clawback defense practice, handles Chapter 7 cases, and resolves IRS, EDD and CDTFA trust-fund exposure through its sales tax and payroll tax practice. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Central District of California.

If this month’s money falls short, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before the next payment goes out.