A Roseville dental group’s scheduling software renewal offers a new tier that ranks staff by “reliability” and suggests write-ups. Accepting takes one click; from 2027, that click carries legal duties.
Governor Newsom signed SB 947, AB 1331, AB 1883 and SB 951 on September 30, 2026. This post reflects their chaptered text as of October 23, 2026; clean-up bills in 2027 are likely, as the Governor requested.
Which California workplace AI rules reach a business with 15 to 100 employees?
Sort by headcount first. SB 947 (Stats. 2026, ch. 859), AB 1331 (ch. 851) and AB 1883 (ch. 853) define “employer” by control over wages, hours or working conditions, with no minimum headcount (new Lab. Code §§ 1520(d)(3), 1560(d), 1580(d)). SB 951 (ch. 860), for employers, only changes Cal/WARN notices, and Cal/WARN reaches only a “covered establishment” with 75 or more persons in the prior 12 months (Lab. Code § 1400.5(b)).
Then sort by trigger. SB 947 becomes operative July 1, 2027 (§ 1526.7) and protects employees, not applicants. Its review, notice and data rules apply when an “automated decision system” (AI or statistical tools issuing a score, classification or recommendation) informs discipline or termination; its bans on inferring protected status or punishing workers for using their rights apply to any use. The two surveillance bills carry no delayed date, so under Cal. Const. art. IV, § 8(c)(1) they start January 1, 2027. The first bars surveillance tools in workplace bathrooms; the second bars any surveillance tool “that uses artificial intelligence” to read a worker’s emotions or gather neural data. Penalties are $500 per violation (up to $500 in the surveillance bills), with the Labor Commissioner and prosecutors enforcing; courts may add “punitive damages” and fees.
The Civil Rights Council’s FEHA rules on automated-decision systems took effect October 1, 2025 for employers regularly employing five or more (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, § 11008(f)). They bar discriminatory systems (§ 11009(f)) and require keeping “automated-decision system data” four years (§ 11013(c)). The CPPA’s automated decisionmaking rules (compliance by January 1, 2027, Cal. Code Regs., tit. 11, § 7200(b)) bind only a CCPA “business” under Civ. Code § 1798.140(d): prior-year revenue over $25 million as adjusted ($26,625,000 per the CPPA, effective January 1, 2025), personal information of 100,000 or more consumers or households bought, sold or shared yearly, or half of revenue from selling or sharing it. A typical 30-person company meets none.
Can employees use PAGA to sue over AI scoring or bathroom tracking?
Probably. Lab. Code § 2699(a) lets an aggrieved employee recover Labor Code civil penalties the Labor Commissioner could assess, and none of the four bills carves out PAGA. Section 2699(k)(2) does bar PAGA claims for “a posting, notice, agency reporting, or filing requirement,” which on my reading excludes SB 947’s post-use notice but not the substantive bans.
Small employers get two breaks. With fewer than 100 employees, a company may propose a confidential cure within 33 days of a PAGA notice (§ 2699.3(c)(2)(A)), and penalties are capped at 15 percent if it took “all reasonable steps” beforehand (§ 2699(g)(1)). A written AI policy backed by an enforceable vendor contract is that evidence.
How would the new laws hit an Ontario delivery company with 42 employees?
Illustrative facts: Priyanka owns a last-mile delivery company in Ontario with 42 employees, 30 of them drivers. Her telematics vendor scores harsh braking and idling and runs an in-cab “distraction” camera that infers fatigue; a scheduling app flags late clock-ins. With about $7.5 million of 2026 revenue and no data sales, she is outside Cal/WARN and the CCPA.
The CRD rules reach her now. A score used for discipline “facilitates human decision making regarding an employment benefit” (§ 11008.1(a)), so scores, clips and inputs stay four years, and a model that mistakes a medical condition for fatigue is a disability problem today.
Before January 1, 2027, review the camera. “Emotional state” is undefined; the Governor’s signing message said AB 1883 “lacks key definitions.” Fatigue is arguably physical; stress or agitation labels are not. Section 1581(b) permits tools used “to ensure safety” but does not clearly rescue an AI emotion inference, so I would disable mood and stress outputs and keep fatigue alerts in-cab. Under AB 1331, nothing may monitor the depot restroom, though § 1561(b)(3) allows checking a tool for “one-time entry and exit,” and a badge with no audio, video or AI may go in (§ 1561(c)(2)).
From July 1, 2027, firing a driver whose score fell below 60 cannot rest on the score alone. If it is the primary reason, someone must check it against the clips or a ride-along, he gets a separate written notice, and he may request a description of his data. Her three vendor questions this quarter: what driver-state inferences does it make, and can each be disabled in writing? How many days to deliver one driver’s events, video and scoring inputs? Can restrooms be geofenced out?
What should a California employer demand in its HR software contract?
The duty sits with the employer; the data and model sit with the vendor. A screening vendor can be an “agent” liable as an employer (§ 11008(b); Raines v. U.S. Healthworks Medical Group (2023) 15 Cal.5th 268), but the employer stays liable too. At renewal, I ask for seven terms.
First, a written list of what the tool infers (emotion, stress, engagement, productivity). Second, a data-access covenant: within a fixed period (I ask for ten business days), employee-level data and a description of the inputs behind any score. Without it, the employer cannot corroborate under § 1522(b)(2) or answer a § 1522(d) request.
Third, configuration warranties: bathrooms excluded from capture, no neural data, emotion features off for California workers. Fourth, retention that overrides the vendor’s deletion schedule. SB 947 sets no period, so I default to the CRD’s four years plus an export right before deletion at contract end. Fifth, cooperation: documents and a witness on a deadline if a regulator or court asks. Sixth, 30 days’ notice before any AI feature is added, off until the customer opts in, because SB 947 looks at how an output is used, not at the product label.
Read the “compliance with applicable law” warranty. It usually covers laws governing the vendor, while another clause puts configuration and use on the customer. Ask for a warranty that the service, used as documented, lets the customer comply with Lab. Code §§ 1522, 1524, 1561 and 1581.
Will the vendor’s liability cap hold up under California law?
Usually. The standard SaaS cap is fees paid in the prior 12 months. Civ. Code § 1668 voids contracts exempting anyone from responsibility for “violation of law, whether willful or negligent,” and New England Country Foods, LLC v. VanLaw Food Products, Inc. (Cal. Apr. 24, 2025, No. S282968) held that it “invalidates limitations on damages for willful injury.” The court added that section 1668 “does not preclude parties from limiting their liability for pure breaches of contract,” which is what an employer’s claim over a wrong setting usually is.
If Priyanka pays $16,800 a year (illustrative) and an emotion feature ran on 30 drivers, one $500 penalty each is $15,000, nearly the whole cap, and no statute says whether violations count per driver, shift or inference. For this seventh term, I ask for a carve-out or separate super-cap for losses, including defense costs, caused by the vendor’s breach of its configuration, data and notice promises. Reimbursement of a penalty for the employer’s own violation is unsettled, so tie indemnity to the vendor’s breach, not the word “penalty.”
What should the human-review file contain if a fired employee sues?
Once the employee shows an automated system was used, § 1526.1(c) makes the employer prove it did not rely primarily on it or that it followed §§ 1522 and 1524. (The text oddly says “deactivation.”)
The file holds the score as produced, dated, and what the reviewer examined independently: video, logs, a supervisor’s notes, the worker’s explanation. Add the reviewer’s name and power to overrule, a conclusion dated before the decision was delivered, the notice with proof of delivery, and any data request with its answer. Keep it four years.
| Rule | Effective | Minimum size | Requires or bars | Enforcer | Exposure | Contract term |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SB 947 | July 1, 2027 | None | No discipline or firing solely on ADS; review, notice, data | Labor Commissioner, prosecutors; PAGA likely | $500 per violation; burden shift | Data delivery deadline |
| AB 1331 | Jan. 1, 2027 | None | No bathroom surveillance | Same | Up to $500 per violation | Bathroom exclusion |
| AB 1883 | Jan. 1, 2027 | None | No AI emotion inference or neural data | Same, plus employee | Up to $500 per violation | Inference list |
| SB 951 | Jan. 1, 2027 | 75 at an establishment | Displacement notice content | Employees, local government | Back pay; $500 per day | Rarely relevant |
| CRD ADS rules | Oct. 1, 2025 | 5 | No discriminatory ADS; four-year retention | CRD, FEHA suits | FEHA damages | Retention, export |
| CCPA ADMT rules | Jan. 1, 2027 | CCPA “business” | Pre-use notice, related rights | CPPA | CCPA fines | Service-provider terms |
Frequently Asked Questions
Do California’s new workplace AI laws apply to a business with only a few employees?
Yes for SB 947, AB 1331 and AB 1883, which set no headcount minimum. The CRD rules start at five employees; SB 951 needs 75 at one establishment.
Is a scheduling or timekeeping app an automated decision system?
It can be. If its scores or flags drive discipline or firing, SB 947 treats it as one. A time clock that only records punches is not.
Can I keep dashcams in company vehicles after AB 1883?
Yes. AB 1883 targets AI emotion inference and neural data, not cameras. Turn off mood or stress features and get the vendor’s inference list in writing.
Can a fired employee sue me directly under SB 947?
SB 947 has no express private right of action. State and local enforcers bring cases, and PAGA likely lets employees pursue its civil penalties.
How long should I keep AI scoring data on employees?
At least four years from the record or personnel action, whichever is later, under the CRD rules. SB 947 sets no period, so stop your vendor deleting sooner.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm negotiates software and HR technology agreements through its contract drafting and review practice and helps owners write AI-use rules into operating and shareholder agreements. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California.
If a renewal lands before January 1, 2027, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before you sign it.
