The interest on your loan statement has nearly doubled. One installment posted late, and the lender now charges its default rate on the whole balance. On a private-fund loan against a Fontana warehouse, the refinance payoff can carry tens of thousands of dollars of it.
Before anyone mentions Chapter 11, ask whether California law allows that rate. Often it does not, and that answer follows the loan into bankruptcy.
Can a California lender charge default interest on the whole loan after one late payment?
Usually not before maturity. In Honchariw v. FJM Private Mortgage Fund, LLC, 83 Cal. App. 5th 893 (2022), the borrowers on a $5.6 million bridge loan missed one monthly payment of $39,667. The note added a 10 percent fee on that payment plus 9.99 points of extra interest on the entire unpaid principal. The First District held the combined charge an unlawful penalty; the California Supreme Court denied review.
It was a business loan. Under Cal. Civ. Code § 1671(b), a liquidated damages clause in a non-consumer contract is valid unless the challenger “establishes that the provision was unreasonable,” and the borrowers carried that burden. A late installment costs the lender the use of that installment briefly, plus handling, and nothing on principal not yet due. Charging the whole balance targets the wrong harm.
The court followed Garrett v. Coast & Southern Federal Savings & Loan Assn., 9 Cal. 3d 731 (1973), which called a late charge “measured against the unpaid balance of the loan” punitive, and Ridgley v. Topa Thrift & Loan Assn., 17 Cal. 4th 970 (1998), which struck a late-payment-triggered “prepayment” fee on a developer’s bridge loan. Civ. Code § 2954.4, the 6 percent late-charge cap, covers only owner-occupied home loans.
I found no published California decision from 2023 through October 2026 narrowing Honchariw. In Honchariw v. PMF CA REIT, LLC, 117 Cal. App. 5th 827 (2025), a referee held another lender’s jump from 8.99 to 19.5 percent a penalty and awarded $261,489; that finding was not appealed, and the Supreme Court’s review covers only fees.
What can a California lender still collect after a late payment?
Honchariw never ruled separately on a fee tied only to the missed installment. Garrett lets a lender recover interest for the days its money was withheld plus related administrative costs, so a flat installment fee is measured against those.
Maturity differs. In Thompson v. Gorner, 104 Cal. 168 (1894), a higher rate after the note went unpaid was a contract term, not a penalty, and Honchariw distinguished fully matured loans. Lenders that accelerate will argue the loan matured; Honchariw did not decide that, and I expect it to be the next fight.
Usury is separate. Cal. Const. art. XV, § 1 limits business loans from non-exempt lenders to the higher of 10 percent or 5 percent plus the San Francisco Fed’s advance rate. Banks are exempt, as are real estate loans made or arranged by a licensed broker under Civ. Code § 1916.1. A fund lending directly at 10.5 percent may be over the line before any default.
Did a payoff demand or default notice add interest on your full loan balance? That number tends to reappear in a forbearance agreement or proof of claim, so check it before you sign.
Does a Chapter 11 cure in the Ninth Circuit require paying the default rate?
It once did not. In In re Entz-White Lumber & Supply, Inc., 850 F.2d 1338 (9th Cir. 1988), a debtor curing a matured note under its plan escaped an 18 percent default rate.
Congress added 11 U.S.C. § 1123(d) in 1994: the cure amount “shall be determined in accordance with the underlying agreement and applicable nonbankruptcy law.” In Pacifica L 51 LLC v. New Investments, Inc. (In re New Investments, Inc.), 840 F.3d 1137 (9th Cir. 2016), the Ninth Circuit held Entz-White abrogated: a Washington hotel owner curing its loan owed the default rate Washington law allowed.
That reference is also the limit. California nonbankruptcy law includes section 1671 and Honchariw, so a pre-maturity default rate that is void never enters the cure amount. A California debtor’s first argument, then, is not that equity should excuse the rate but that the lender never had a right to it. It needs no judicial discretion and works in a workout too.
Does an oversecured lender get default interest in a California Chapter 11?
A lender whose collateral is worth more than the debt earns post-petition interest under 11 U.S.C. § 506(b). United States v. Ron Pair Enterprises, Inc., 489 U.S. 235 (1989), read that section so the reasonableness limit governs fees and charges, not interest. General Electric Capital Corp. v. Future Media Productions Inc., 536 F.3d 969 (9th Cir. 2008), presumes the contract default rate applies “provided that the rate is not unenforceable under applicable nonbankruptcy law,” subject to equitable considerations. Section 502(b)(1) applies the same state-law screen to pre-petition charges.
In New York, Judge Bentley allowed default interest but not a late charge on top in In re 33 Mako, LLC, No. 25-11256 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Apr. 4, 2026). In In re 1300 Desert Willow Road, LLC, No. 25-11375 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. July 21, 2026), about a New Mexico factory, he gave the fresh-start argument little weight for a single-asset debtor without real operations.
A Riverside judge is bound by neither. The one-or-the-other rule fits Garrett’s view that a lender is paid once for delay, and I would expect California courts to agree. The bigger difference: New York weighs penalty among the equities, while under Future Media a California rate that fails section 1671 never reaches them.
How would this play out for a Fontana industrial building?
Illustrative facts: Teodoro’s LLC owns a leased Fontana industrial building with a $3.2 million interest-only bridge loan from a private lender at 10.5 percent, maturing August 2027, with an 18 percent default rate and a 10 percent late charge. The $28,000 September 2026 installment posted 12 days late.
The step-up is 7.5 points on $3.2 million: $240,000 a year, or $20,000 a month. By mid-January 2027 about $90,000 is in the payoff, none of it owed under Honchariw. The $2,800 late charge is a closer call. Twelve days of interest on $28,000 at the note rate is about $97, which helps Teodoro, though the burden is his. After August 2027, 18 percent on an unpaid matured balance is likely enforceable.
Now the LLC files Chapter 11 on January 15, 2027, in the Central District’s Riverside Division (which hears San Bernardino County cases), with the building worth $4.5 million. A cure is the missed installments at 10.5 percent plus any surviving late charge. Section 506(b) interest runs at 10.5 percent against a cushion above $1 million, with a claim to 18 percent only if the case outlasts maturity.
A building producing substantially all of the LLC’s income is single asset real estate under 11 U.S.C. § 101(51B), which also keeps the LLC out of Subchapter V under § 101(51D). Under § 362(d)(3), by April 15, 2027 (90 days after the order for relief, absent an extension) it needs a confirmable plan on file or monthly payments at the “nondefault contract rate,” about $28,000 here.
What should I check before signing a forbearance agreement with my lender?
Get the payoff demand in writing, with interest broken out by rate and date, and recompute it first. In my experience these demands carry default interest nobody checked against Honchariw, and the forbearance draft then has the borrower acknowledge it and waive defenses. That is the lender’s fix for the penalty problem. In Desert Willow, a lump-sum late fee survived because it appeared in the debtor’s own forbearance agreement, which the debtor never attacked.
A forbearance can also raise usury. In Milestone Financial, LLC v. Moon (In re Moon), 648 B.R. 73 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 2023), a forbearance negotiated without a broker lost the section 1916.1 exemption; SB 1146 (Stats. 2024, ch. 601) now covers broker-arranged forbearances. My post on carveout guaranties covers the guarantor’s side.
| Situation | California contract rule | Ninth Circuit bankruptcy rule | What the borrower should do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Late installment before maturity | Whole-balance default rate is a penalty (Honchariw) | Void charges disallowed (§ 502(b)(1)) | Demand a recomputed payoff |
| Loan past maturity | Higher rate generally enforceable (Thompson) | Presumed allowed if oversecured | Refinance or file before maturity |
| Chapter 11 cure under plan | Contract as limited by § 1671 | Default rate owed only if enforceable (§ 1123(d)) | Lead with the penalty argument |
| Oversecured lender post-petition (§ 506(b)) | Same enforceability test | Default rate presumed, rebuttable on equities (Future Media) | Track the equity cushion |
| Undersecured lender | Same limits on the claim | No post-petition interest (§ 502(b)(2)) | Object to void charges |
| Forbearance signed after default | A new agreement, tested again under § 1671 | No Ninth Circuit ruling found; Desert Willow allowed an agreed fee | Recompute first; strike the reaffirmation |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 10 percent late charge legal on a California commercial loan?
It can be, if reasonable measured against the installment. Section 2954.4’s 6 percent cap reaches only owner-occupied home loans. On a business loan, the borrower must prove the charge unreasonable under section 1671(b).
Does Honchariw apply to bank loans?
Honchariw involved a private fund, but its rule rests on section 1671 and Garrett, a savings and loan case. A bank’s usury exemption does not decide whether its default rate is a penalty.
Can I recover default interest I already paid at a refinance?
Possibly. The PMF CA REIT borrowers paid default interest in a payoff, then sued and won a referee’s award of $261,489. Limitations periods apply, so do not wait.
Can a Chapter 11 cure avoid the default rate?
Not on bankruptcy grounds alone since section 1123(d). A cure pays what the contract and state law require. If California law voids the rate, the cure leaves it out; after maturity, it probably includes it.
What if my lender is undersecured?
It earns no post-petition interest: section 502(b)(2) disallows unmatured interest, and section 506(b) helps only oversecured creditors. Its claim is still limited to charges enforceable under California law.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm represents California borrowers in loan workouts and bankruptcy cases, including Subchapter V for operating companies, and reviews forbearance terms through its contract drafting and review practice. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the bankruptcy court for the Central District of California.
If your loan jumped to a default rate, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before you sign a forbearance.
