The call usually comes in the fall. A new recordkeeper tells a California owner that two employees hired last year were never enrolled in the 401(k), or that spring deferrals sat in the operating account for three weeks. The owner adopted the plan for CalSavers and assumed the payroll vendor ran it.
Most of these you can now fix without IRS permission. California adds a question the IRS never asks: does a badly run plan still keep you out of CalSavers?
Can I fix a 401(k) mistake without filing with the IRS under Rev. Proc. 2026-34?
Rev. Proc. 2026-34, effective October 22, 2026, replaces Rev. Proc. 2021-30 as the IRS correction system (EPCRS), locking in the relief from section 305 of SECURE 2.0 (Pub. L. 117-328) and Notice 2023-43. Under the IRS Self-Correction Program (SCP), you fix the error and keep the paperwork, with nothing filed. A 401(k) no longer needs a favorable IRS letter to qualify, and SEPs and SIMPLE IRAs on an IRS model form or approved prototype can use SCP too.
A fix is deemed timely if done before the third plan year following the failure year closes, or within 18 months of finding it, whichever is later (section 7.05). You also need practices in place when the error happened; the IRS warns that “A plan document alone does not constitute evidence of established procedures.”
Never adopting a plan document stays outside SCP, as does curing an error with a backward amendment that cuts benefits (section 7.03) and any egregious failure (section 5.06). A benefit overpaid by mistake generally need not be recovered, but one that breaches a Code limit must be unless it is under $250 (section 6.12). A VCP filing for IRS approval starts at a $2,000 user fee in 2026.
Does a 401(k), SEP or SIMPLE with mistakes still exempt my California business from CalSavers?
Since December 31, 2025, every California employer with an eligible employee has needed CalSavers or its own plan (Cal. Gov. Code § 100032(e)). Subdivision (h) exempts an employer offering a 401(k), SEP or SIMPLE “if the plan or IRA qualifies for favorable federal income tax treatment.” The penalty is $250 per eligible employee on the Franchise Tax Board’s first notice, plus $500 per employee if you still have not complied 90 days later (Gov. Code § 100033; Rev. & Tax. Code § 19287; FTB guidance).
My read, untested by any court or agency: correcting ordinary errors under EPCRS preserves the plan’s tax treatment, so the exemption holds. The risk is a plan that exists mostly on paper, like a SIMPLE that no longer gets deposits or a 401(k) that leaves most staff out. The regulations exempt an employer that “maintains or contributes to” a qualified plan (Cal. Code Regs. tit. 10, § 10000); if the board decides you do neither, the penalty and the correction bill arrive together.
What mistakes do small 401(k) plans run through payroll make, and how are they fixed?
Late deposits
For plans under 100 participants, deferrals deposited by the seventh business day after payday are deemed timely (29 C.F.R. § 2510.3-102(a)(2)). Later money is a prohibited transaction outside EPCRS (section 6.15). You deposit lost earnings from the DOL online calculator and owe a 15 percent excise tax under 26 U.S.C. § 4975(a) on the lost interest, not the deposits (Form 5330 instructions). Since March 2025, the DOL’s Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program lets you fix it alone when lost earnings are $1,000 or less and the money went in within 180 days, paying the excise amount into the plan and filing an online notice.
Employees left out
I see this most, usually from a bad payroll flag. The standard fix is a qualified nonelective contribution (QNEC) of half the employee’s “missed deferral,” plus the missed match and earnings. A gap of three months or less needs no QNEC if deferrals start promptly and the employee gets notice within 45 days. For longer gaps, starting correct deferrals within three plan years after the failure year cuts the QNEC to 25 percent (Appendix section .05(9)). Automatic enrollment plans owe none if fixed within 9½ months after the failure year (section .05(8)).
The wrong pay counted
Plan documents often count all wages while payroll sends only base pay, and daily overtime under Lab. Code § 510 widens that gap in California (see our post on California daily overtime). The fix is a QNEC on the deferral that pay would have produced, plus the match; amending the plan backward to drop overtime cuts benefits, which SCP forbids.
Unpaid participant loans
When loan deductions stop, the loan can become a taxable deemed distribution under 26 U.S.C. § 72(p). The fix is to make up missed payments with interest, reamortize over the rest of the original term, or both, if that term has not expired (section 6.13); on a default, the IRS expects the employer to pay the added interest.
Amendments nobody signed
Notice 2024-2 set December 31, 2026 for most private 401(k) plans to adopt SECURE 2.0 amendments. A September 16, 2026 IRS bulletin ties that date to discretionary features already in use, like Roth employer contributions; required amendments come later. Notice 2026-9 gives SEPs and SIMPLE IRAs until December 31, 2027. Sign what your provider sent.
How would a Roseville dental lab fix a missed enrollment and late deposits?
Illustrative example: Hannah owns a Roseville dental lab with 22 employees. She adopted a safe harbor 401(k) in 2023, partly to answer CalSavers, matching 100 percent of deferrals up to 4 percent of pay. In October 2026 she learns two technicians hired in 2024 were never offered enrollment and six 2025 payrolls were deposited about 20 days late.
Her SCP window runs to April 2028, 18 months after discovery. Take a technician earning $52,000 excluded for 2025. With the match running to 4 percent, the missed deferral is 4 percent of pay, $2,080 (Appendix section .05(2)(c)); the standard QNEC is half, $1,040. Starting correct deferrals before 2028, with notice within 45 days, drops it to $520 under the 25 percent method. She still owes the $2,080 match, earnings on both, and prorated amounts for 2024 and 2026.
Say each late payroll carried $4,200 and the calculator, at an assumed 7 percent rate, shows about $16 of lost earnings each, roughly $97 in all. Under the DOL limit, she deposits it, pays about $15 of excise into the plan instead of filing Form 5330, files the online notice, and amends her 2025 Form 5500-SF. Her records should track section 7.05(2)(b). All figures are illustrative.
I have a SIMPLE IRA with a few employees. Does any of this apply to me?
Yes. Picture a Temecula contractor with four employees who skipped the 3 percent SIMPLE match for two years and enrolled a newer worker a year late. Under 26 U.S.C. § 408(p), that match is mandatory, and anyone paid $5,000 in any two prior years and expected to earn that this year must be let in. He makes fully vested makeup contributions with earnings (section 6.17(3)), but only a plan on Form 5305-SIMPLE, Form 5304-SIMPLE or an approved prototype can use SCP.
A SIMPLE generally must be the employer’s only plan for the year (§ 408(p)(2)(D)). The traditional exit, per the IRS SIMPLE IRA FAQs, is telling employees before November 2 that it ends January 1, already too late for 2027. SECURE 2.0 section 332 allows ending it midyear when a safe harbor 401(k) replaces it, with 30 days’ notice (Notice 2024-2, Part G).
If my payroll company runs the 401(k), why is it my problem when I sell?
Nearly every payroll agreement I read names the employer, not the vendor, as plan administrator and fiduciary. If one provider error hit many plans, the provider can now file a group VCP submission once 10 plans are affected, down from 20 (section 9.11).
These errors surface at a sale or in a wage claim. Buyer’s counsel will ask for recent Form 5500s and a compliance representation. A documented SCP fix or a VCP compliance statement answers it; an open failure becomes an indemnity or a price cut, and in a stock sale the buyer inherits the plan.
| Question | Late deposits | Employee left out | Wrong pay counted | Loan default | Unsigned amendment | SIMPLE or SEP shortfall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fix under IRS SCP? | No; use DOL VFCP | Yes | Yes, but no benefit cuts | Yes, if term not expired | Yes | Yes, model form or prototype |
| Window | Within 180 days | 25% QNEC within three plan years | SCP window | Before loan term ends | SCP window | SCP window |
| What you pay | Lost earnings; 15% excise on interest | 25% or 50% QNEC, match, earnings | QNEC, match, earnings | Makeup payments; employer covers interest | Nothing under SCP | Makeup contribution, earnings |
| Program | DOL VFCP | IRS SCP | IRS SCP | IRS SCP plus DOL notice | IRS SCP or VCP ($2,000 and up) | IRS SCP |
| Keep | Calculator printout, notice, checklist | Census, notice, QNEC math | Pay codes, plan definition | Schedule, payment proof | Signed amendment | Form 5305 or 5304, deposits |
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to tell the IRS when I fix a 401(k) mistake myself?
No. SCP has no filing and no fee. You keep the records in case the plan is examined.
How long do I have to fix an error under Rev. Proc. 2026-34?
Until the third plan year following the failure year closes, or 18 months after you find the error, whichever is later. An IRS exam generally ends it.
Can my SIMPLE IRA or SEP use the Self-Correction Program?
Yes, if the plan was adopted on the IRS model form or an approved prototype. A custom document needs VCP.
Will fixing my 401(k) protect my CalSavers exemption?
In my view, yes: a corrected plan keeps the favorable federal tax treatment Government Code section 100032(h) requires. A plan that exists only on paper is riskier, and no agency has addressed it.
What does a VCP filing cost in 2026?
It depends on plan assets: $2,000 for $500,000 or less, $3,500 up to $10 million, and $4,000 above that, for submissions made in 2026. Fees can change each January.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reviews and corrects retirement plan failures for California owners. It handles plan diligence when buying or selling a business, seeks penalty abatement on assessed excise or filing penalties, and advises on entity formation and plan choice. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA, admitted to the U.S. Tax Court.
If your plan has an error, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation.
