A broker has told you your employees could buy the company. You are in your sixties, no child wants it, and the competitors who call want your customer list more than your crews. The broker said ESOP, and mentioned a new federal law that makes these deals safer.
The law is real. It protects the trustee who buys your shares, though, not your price, and it does nothing to what California collects.
How does selling a California company to an ESOP actually work?
An employee stock ownership plan is a retirement plan that holds mostly employer stock. The company adopts the plan and a trust, and an independent trustee negotiates for the employees. The trust borrows, usually from the company, which borrows from a bank, and buys your shares at appraised value. A seller note, often with warrants, covers the gap.
The company then funds the plan to repay that loan. A C corporation can deduct contributions applied to principal up to 25 percent of covered payroll, plus interest, under 26 U.S.C. § 404(a)(9). That rule “shall not apply to an S corporation,” so an S corporation ESOP often repays with distributions on the trust’s shares.
Under California law you are selling stock, not assets, so the shareholder vote in Cal. Corp. Code § 1001 does not apply. Transfer restrictions in the articles or a shareholder agreement do (Corp. Code § 204(b)), and other owners’ rights of first refusal and buyout terms must be waived or amended first.
What did the Retire Through Ownership Act change about ESOP valuations?
A plan may buy its sponsor’s stock only for “adequate consideration” (29 U.S.C. § 1108(e)). For private stock, 29 U.S.C. § 1002(18) meant fair market value the trustee set in good faith, under Labor Department rules proposed in 1988 (53 Fed. Reg. 17,632) and never finalized.
The Ninth Circuit’s leading case involved a California company. In Howard v. Shay, 100 F.3d 1484 (9th Cir. 1996), the court reversed a judgment for the fiduciaries of Pacific Architects and Engineers’ ESOP, holding that an appraisal “is not a magic wand that fiduciaries may simply wave over a transaction.” In Brundle v. Wilmington Trust, N.A., 919 F.3d 763 (4th Cir. 2019), a trustee was held liable for a $29,773,250 overpayment.
The Retire through Ownership Act, Pub. L. 119-124 (S. 2403), signed October 15, 2026, lets an ESOP fiduciary rely in good faith on an independent appraiser who applied Rev. Rul. 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237, for determinations made on or after that date. The ruling’s eight factors run from the company’s history and industry outlook through book value, earnings, dividend capacity, goodwill, prior stock sales, and comparable public company prices.
I read the safe harbor narrowly. The Act states that it does not “modify a fiduciary’s obligations under section 404,” so the Howard duties to vet the appraiser and give it accurate numbers remain. A protected trustee may close at the appraised figure more readily. Nothing in the Act raises that figure.
Does California allow the section 1042 rollover, and can an S corporation owner use it?
California conforms. Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 18042 adopts 26 U.S.C. § 1042, so gain deferred federally is deferred on Form 540 too. You need C corporation stock held three years, an ESOP owning at least 30 percent afterward, and a company consent statement. You must buy qualified replacement property, meaning securities of domestic operating companies, within three months before or twelve months after closing. Under § 409(n), the shares cannot be allocated to you, your relatives, or any 25 percent owner.
S corporation stock is excluded today. SECURE 2.0 (Pub. L. 117-328, § 114) allows deferral on no more than 10 percent of the amount realized for sales after December 31, 2027, and § 18042(c), added by SB 711, follows for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2028. Full deferral still requires C status at closing.
Does a 100 percent ESOP owned S corporation pay California tax?
Federally, no. An ESOP may hold S corporation stock, and 26 U.S.C. § 512(e)(3) keeps its share of income out of unrelated business income. At 100 percent ESOP ownership, nobody pays federal income tax on the profit.
California is different. Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 23802 taxes the S corporation itself at 1.5 percent of net income, with the $800 minimum, whoever owns it. The trust’s exemption never reaches a tax on the corporation. A C corporation pays 8.84 percent, per the FTB’s rate table.
Illustrative example: Priya, 63, owns all of a Fresno commercial HVAC S corporation with 45 employees, appraised at $12,000,000 and earning about $2,400,000 a year before tax. The ESOP buys 100 percent with $6,000,000 of bank debt and a $6,000,000 seller note. Assume her stock basis is $1,500,000, so her gain is $10,500,000.
Federally that is capital gain, mostly at the 20 percent top rate, or roughly $2.1 million. She can report the note portion as collected (§ 453), with a § 453A interest charge because the note tops $5 million. California has no capital gain rate. Filing jointly on the 2025 schedule (2026 figures are not posted), most of the gain is taxed at 12.3 percent plus the 1 percent Behavioral Health Services Tax, formerly the mental health tax, on income over $1 million: about $1.35 million if recognized in one year.
After closing, the company’s $2,400,000 draws no federal income tax. California still collects 1.5 percent, or $36,000 a year once loan contributions stop shrinking the base. She could instead revoke the S election and use § 1042 to defer both taxes. The price: 21 percent federal and 8.84 percent California tax on income left after ESOP deductions, no new S election for five years (§ 1362(g)), and up to $12,000,000 of replacement securities to buy within a year while half her price sits in a note.
Which ESOP rules trip up a smaller California company?
Under 26 U.S.C. § 409(p), anyone holding 10 percent of an S corporation ESOP’s deemed-owned shares, or 20 percent with family, is a disqualified person. If those people own half or more of the company, allocations to them become taxable distributions and a § 4979A excise tax applies. With five employees, nearly everyone crosses 10 percent. Warrants on a seller note count as synthetic equity and can make the seller disqualified herself.
Cash demands follow. Under 26 U.S.C. § 401(a)(28), a participant 55 or older with ten years in the plan may diversify 25 percent of the account, and 50 percent in the final election year. Under § 409(h), departing employees can make the company buy back their shares, with payment spread over as long as five years. With California turnover, buybacks come every year, so I want a funded reserve before the first. Every year also brings an independent appraisal (§ 401(a)(28)(C)).
When is an ESOP the wrong exit for a California owner?
When a buyer will pay for synergies an appraiser will not count. Advisers often cite $150,000 to $400,000 in professional fees for a first ESOP, an illustrative range rather than a quote, plus yearly administration. In my view a company under about $2 million of EBITDA or 20 employees rarely pencils.
A management buyout with seller financing is simpler. So is a sale to a competitor, where the purchase agreement carries the risk, as my post on purchase agreement terms explains. Employees can also organize a worker cooperative under the Cooperative Corporation Law (Corp. Code § 12200; at least 51 percent of workers must be members or candidates under § 12253.5), or shares can go to an employee ownership trust, which has no special federal tax regime. California’s Employee Ownership Hub (Gov. Code § 12100.33, from SB 1407) exists only upon appropriation and offers education and referrals, not financing.
| Issue | Sale to a strategic buyer | ESOP sale (C corporation, § 1042) | ESOP sale (S corporation) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who buys | Competitor or investor | ESOP trust, usually with borrowed money | ESOP trust, usually with borrowed money |
| Price standard | Negotiated, may include synergies | Appraised fair market value | Appraised fair market value |
| Seller’s federal gain | Taxed, top 20% rate | Deferred if replacement property bought | Taxed; 10% deferral only for sales after 2027 |
| Seller’s California gain | Taxed as ordinary income, up to 13.3% | Deferred (§ 18042) | Taxed, up to 13.3% |
| Company federal income tax after | Depends on buyer | 21% on income after ESOP deductions | None at 100% ESOP ownership |
| Company California tax after | Depends on buyer | 8.84% | 1.5% plus $800 minimum |
| Employee protections | Employment law only | Diversification at 55, put rights | Same, plus § 409(p) limits |
| Timeline drivers | Buyer diligence and financing | Trustee, appraisal, lender, plan documents | Same, plus § 409(p) testing |
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Retire Through Ownership Act become law?
Yes. S. 2403 was signed on October 15, 2026, as Public Law 119-124. It applies to ESOP valuation determinations made on or after that date.
Does the new law guarantee my ESOP sale price?
No. It protects a trustee who relies in good faith on an independent appraisal that follows Revenue Ruling 59-60. The price is still fair market value, and the trustee’s prudence duties remain.
Does California tax the gain if I use a section 1042 rollover?
Not at the time of sale. California adopts section 1042 through Revenue and Taxation Code section 18042, so a qualifying C corporation sale is deferred on both returns.
Is an ESOP owned S corporation free of California tax?
No. The company still pays California’s 1.5 percent S corporation tax on net income, with an $800 minimum. Only the federal income tax disappears at 100 percent ESOP ownership.
Can a company with five employees set up an S corporation ESOP?
Rarely. With so few participants, most hold at least 10 percent of the deemed-owned shares, which tends to create a nonallocation year under section 409(p) and triggers penalty taxes.
Will California’s Employee Ownership Hub help finance the sale?
No. The statute creates an information and referral office, set up only when the Legislature funds it. Financing still comes from banks, the seller, or both.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm advises California owners on buying and selling a business, models the federal and California tax on each exit through business sale tax structuring, and reviews the shareholder agreements that must be cleared before an employee sale can close. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA.
If you are weighing an ESOP against an outside offer, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation.
