North Star Law Firm logoNorth Star Law Firm
☰

California Property Tax on Your Business Intangibles: Olympic & Georgia and Nov. 30

A row of single story motel rooms with red tile roofs facing an empty parking lot in Barstow, San Bernardino County, California

Written by

in

Jared bought a franchised hotel in Ontario last March. This fall the San Bernardino County assessor mailed a supplemental assessment treating his whole $9.5 million price as land and building, though the price also bought a brand and a trained staff. (Jared is illustrative.)

California does not tax most of that as real property. Whether his bill reflects it depends on proof, and on a deadline: in much of Southern California, the regular 2026 appeal window closes Monday, Nov. 30.

Does California property tax apply to a franchise, a trained staff or goodwill?

Not directly. Cal. Const. art. XIII, §§ 1 and 2 tax property at fair market value, but the Legislature exempted intangibles. Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code § 212(c) exempts intangible assets and rights. Section 110(d) requires removing the value of going concern intangibles when a business is valued as a unit.

Section 110(e) lets the assessor assume the intangibles needed to operate are present, and § 110(f) keeps location and zoning in the value. A busy Temecula corner is real estate; the loyal lunch crowd is not. Hotels are usually valued by capitalizing income under Property Tax Rule 8 (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 8), and Rule 8(e) requires excluding enough operating income to give a return on nontaxable assets.

What did the California Supreme Court decide in Olympic & Georgia Partners?

Olympic & Georgia Partners, LLC v. County of Los Angeles, 18 Cal. 5th 739 (2025) (No. S280000), concerned the Ritz-Carlton and JW Marriott tower by the Los Angeles Convention Center. Justice Groban, for four justices, let the assessor count the city’s assignment of its 14 percent occupancy tax and a one time key money payment from Marriott, reasoning that both were income the property itself earns rather than business income. The court called that ruling narrow and said other subsidies must be judged individually.

The holding small owners need was unanimous. The county sought what the court called “a blanket endorsement of the Rushmore Method,” the idea that deducting the management fee removes all enterprise value. Refused: once an owner identifies and values an enterprise asset, the assessor must produce evidence the fee covers it. The enterprise assets went back to the appeals board. Justice Liu would have excluded key money; Justice Kruger, with Justice Evans, would have excluded both payments. No Letter To Assessors has followed, and a Board of Equalization work group on intangibles met in June 2026 without issuing guidance.

It refines Elk Hills Power, LLC v. Board of Equalization, 57 Cal. 4th 593 (2013), which required deducting goodwill and favorable franchise terms. In SHC Half Moon Bay, LLC v. County of San Mateo, 226 Cal. App. 4th 471 (2014), a hotel owner won removal of its workforce but lost on goodwill because the fees captured it. EHP Glendale, LLC v. County of Los Angeles, 193 Cal. App. 4th 262 (2011), sent a challenge to an assessment built on a hotel’s purchase price back for trial.

How does a purchase price allocation change a California base year value?

A purchase is the first exposure; the assessor sets a new base year value as of the transfer date (R&TC §§ 110.1, 75.10). Section 110(b) and Property Tax Rule 2(b) presume an arm’s length price is that value, rebuttable only by a gap above 5 percent. When the deal includes more than real estate, § 110(c) requires the change in ownership statement to break down the price, or the presumption is lost.

That statement is usually Form BOE-502-A. Part 4 asks about business property in the price, with no line for franchise or goodwill, and the instructions require a detailed list. A buyer who checks No has given the county one number with a presumption attached.

Under 26 U.S.C. § 1060, buyer and seller allocate the price by the residual method and each files Form 8594, with real estate and furniture in Class V and franchise, workforce, licenses and goodwill in Classes VI and VII. As a CPA I read the two forms together: if Jared amortizes $1.5 million of intangibles federally while telling the assessor every dollar bought real estate, one statement is wrong. Sellers have their own allocation traps, covered in what a buyer’s $1 purchase agreement can cost a seller.

The illustrative math: Jared paid $9,500,000 in March 2026, including franchise rights, staff and $400,000 of furniture and equipment. Enrolled whole at an assumed 1.1 percent rate (actual rates vary), the bill is $104,500. With $7,600,000 on land and building, $400,000 on furniture and $1,500,000 on intangibles, the real property tax is $83,600. The furniture is still taxed as business personal property (R&TC §§ 201, 441; Form 571-L).

The intangibles alone cost $16,500 a year. With Proposition 13’s annual increase of up to 2 percent (Cal. Const. art. XIII A, § 2(b)), ten years at the full 2 percent totals about $180,670. Furniture left inside the real property figure and also reported on the 571-L is taxed twice.

The annual bill is the second exposure. Value then rises 2 percent at most, or drops to a lower Jan. 1 market value (R&TC § 51, the Proposition 8 rule). So the fight matters most in the base year, and after a Prop 8 reduction, when fresh valuations let business income creep back in.

When is the 2026 deadline to appeal a property tax assessment in my California county?

Under R&TC § 1603(b), the regular period runs July 2 to Sept. 15, extended to Nov. 30 where the assessor does not mail value notices by Aug. 1. The Board of Equalization’s certified list, Letter To Assessors No. 2026/023, puts Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, Sacramento, Fresno and San Diego on Nov. 30, 2026. San Francisco, Santa Clara, Alameda and Ventura closed Sept. 15. From this post’s Nov. 9 date, that is three weeks.

Supplemental and escape assessments run 60 days from the mailing date on the notice (R&TC §§ 75.31, 1605(b)), or from the tax bill in Los Angeles County. A sale between Jan. 1 and May 31 produces two supplemental assessments (§ 75.11), and Jared gets 60 days on each San Bernardino notice. The county’s Nov. 30 deadline covers his 2026-27 regular bill, which still carries the seller’s Jan. 1 value. Miss those, and § 80(a)(3) still allows a later base year appeal, with relief only going forward.

The application states your opinion of value, which § 1604(c) generally enrolls if the board fails to decide within two years. Business owners carry the burden: the presumption in R&TC § 167 covers owner occupied homes and escape assessment appeals, and Property Tax Rule 321 otherwise requires independent evidence. Above $100,000 of assessed value, either side may start an exchange of information under § 1606.

Did you just get a supplemental assessment, or buy a California business with its building this year? Most Southern California counties close regular appeals Nov. 30, 2026, and a supplemental notice allows only 60 days.

What evidence wins an intangibles appeal before a California assessment appeals board?

Owners I talk with often bring a profit and loss statement showing the hotel lost money. That is a Prop 8 argument, and R&TC § 1610.8 still demands independent evidence of value. A P&L never separates the business from the building.

What works after Olympic & Georgia is a going concern appraisal that values the whole hotel, then values and deducts each enterprise asset with a method a hearing officer can follow, such as the cost of training replacement staff. The county must then answer with evidence; the majority said “merely referencing an article regarding the Rushmore Method” was not enough.

For a Temecula restaurant building bought with the restaurant, the opinion repeats an old rule: the assessor may assume a liquor license exists but may not add its price. A § 1606 exchange makes the assessor disclose its income data, where a lone fee deduction is easy to spot.

ItemTaxable as real property?Who must prove itWhere reported at purchase
Franchise or flag affiliationNo; fee deduction may not remove itOwner first, then the assessorBOE-502-A list; Form 8594 Class VI
Assembled workforceNoOwnerBOE-502-A list; Form 8594 Class VI
GoodwillNoOwner; otherwise fees may cover itBOE-502-A list; Form 8594 Class VII
Liquor licensePrice no; presence assumedOwner shows price paidBOE-502-A list; Form 8594 Class VI
Key moneyYes, on Olympic’s factsOwner must distinguish its dealBOE-502-A Part 3 special terms
Government subsidy tied to the propertyCase by caseOwner shows it rewards the businessBOE-502-A Part 3 special terms
Furniture and equipmentNo; business personal propertyOwner reports yearlyBOE-502-A Part 4; Form 571-L; Form 8594 Class V

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Nov. 30, 2026 the appeal deadline in every California county?

No. Counties that mail value notices by Aug. 1, including San Francisco, Santa Clara, Alameda and Ventura, closed Sept. 15. Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, Sacramento and Fresno run to Nov. 30.

I bought my building this year. Which deadline applies to the new value?

The supplemental notice, which gives you 60 days from its mailing date in most counties. If you miss it, a later regular period still lets you challenge the base year value, but only going forward.

Can I lower my assessment by showing my hotel lost money?

Not by itself. Losses may support a Prop 8 claim, but the board wants market evidence of value on Jan. 1, not an income statement.

Does deducting my franchise fee remove the brand value from my assessment?

Not automatically. Once you value an enterprise asset, the assessor must prove the fee covers it. Offer no valuation and the fee deduction may be treated as enough.

Should my BOE-502-A match the Form 8594 I file with the IRS?

It should. Both describe one purchase, and buyer and seller each file Form 8594. A real property figure that contradicts your federal allocation invites questions from the assessor or the IRS.

How North Star Law Firm Can Help

North Star Law Firm builds allocations that hold up with the assessor and the IRS through its real estate tax strategy and business purchase and sale work, and defends challenged values and allocations through its tax defense practice. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Tax Court.

If you are holding an assessment notice or buying a business with its building, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation.