You held a piece of a California operating business through an LLC, moved to Nevada or Arizona, and sold the stake. Your preparer reported the part of the gain tied to the company’s inventory and receivables as California income, because a 2022 Franchise Tax Board (FTB) ruling said to.
On July 24, 2026, the Office of Tax Appeals, or OTA, said that split has no basis in California law, in In the Matter of the Consolidated Appeals of J. Burch, J. Carden and K. Carden, OTA Case Nos. 230112266 and 230112267, 2026-OTA-527P. Whether it helps you depends on how you held the interest and whether you had really left.
Listen to this post
North Star Tax and Legal Briefing: Sold an LLC Interest After Leaving California? What Burch and Carden Changes
A nonresident sold an LLC interest and the FTB taxed the inventory and receivables slice as California income. This episode covers what the Office of Tax Appeals said in Burch and Carden, who the decision does not help, and the refund window.
Download the MP3 · Episode page on Podbean
Show / hide the episode transcript
You owned a slice of a California operating business through an LLC. You moved to Nevada or Arizona. Then you sold the interest. Your preparer reported part of that gain as California income, because a twenty twenty-two Franchise Tax Board ruling said to. On the illustrative facts in our post, a former Irvine resident with a nine hundred thousand dollar gain owes California roughly twenty-three and a half thousand dollars under the FTB’s position. Under a July twenty twenty-six decision from California’s Office of Tax Appeals, that tax is zero. The decision is called Burch and Carden, and the refund clock is already running.
California residents pay tax on everything they earn, anywhere. Nonresidents pay only on income with a California source. So once you have actually left, the whole fight is about source. An interest in a partnership, or an LLC taxed as a partnership, is intangible property, like a stock or a bond. A nonresident’s gain on intangible property follows the owner home, unless the property has picked up a business situs in California, which is rare for a passive owner. Now hold this distinction. A separate rule apportions a nonresident partner’s share of the partnership’s operating income to California. That rule governs income from running the business. The question in Burch and Carden was whether it also reaches income from selling your stake, because the federal code treats the part of your price tied to inventory and receivables, the so-called hot assets, as ordinary income. The FTB built its ruling on that wrinkle.
The FTB’s twenty twenty-two ruling treated one sale as two. First the partnership is deemed to sell its hot assets, and that piece is apportioned to California like operating income. The rest of the gain goes home with the nonresident. The appellants were nonresidents whose holding partnership owned about twenty-eight percent of Tory Burch, the fashion company, and sold pieces of that stake in twenty twelve and twenty thirteen. The dollars were small, about fifteen hundred dollars of tax for one couple. The principle was not. On July twenty-fourth, twenty twenty-six, the Office of Tax Appeals, or OTA, declined to follow the ruling. The panel leaned on a recent federal appeals court decision holding that the hot asset rule changes the character of the gain, not the transaction. You still sold an intangible interest, so the gain goes home with you. Here is the part that cuts the other way. The panel never called the FTB’s position unwise. It found no statute or regulation behind it, and it noted the Legislature changed the rule for corporate partners back in nineteen eighty-eight after the FTB lost a similar fight. That reads like an invitation. Nothing in the decision orders auditors to stop, and as of late October it was still listed as pending precedential.
Whether this helps you turns on two questions. First, how did you hold the interest? If you owned it directly and were a nonresident on the sale date, all of the gain, hot asset slice included, goes home with you. If you held it through a holding LLC that also managed the operating company, expect the FTB to call the two unitary and apportion the entire gain, not just the slice. In the Smith case the OTA did exactly that. On our illustrative facts, that structural choice moves the California tax from zero to about eighty-five thousand dollars. Second, had you really left? Sourcing touches only the hot asset piece. Residency reaches everything. When a sale closes within a year or two of a move, expect the FTB to test the move first, so the paperwork of leaving matters as much as the sale documents.
Three things to do this week. One, pull the return for the year of the sale and look at how the gain was sourced. If you held the interest directly and paid tax on a hot asset slice, a refund claim is reasonable, and the deadline runs from your own filing and payment dates, generally four years from a timely return or one year from payment. Two, if you are already in a protest or an OTA appeal, put this decision in front of the protest officer or panel in writing now. Three, if you have not sold yet, look at your holding structure before the sale, not after. That’s what we do at North Star Law Firm. The initial consultation is free, and the full written analysis with citations is at C A dash legal dot net.
Does California tax a nonresident who sells an LLC or partnership interest?
Residents pay on all income; nonresidents pay only on California-source income (Rev. & Tax. Code § 17041). Once you live elsewhere, the fight is over source.
Under Rev. & Tax. Code § 17952, a nonresident’s income from “stocks, bonds, notes, or other intangible personal property” is not California income “unless the property has acquired a business situs in this state.” An interest in a partnership, or an LLC taxed as one, is intangible, so gain on selling it normally follows you home. FTB’s regulation 17952 finds a business situs mainly where the property is used as capital here, which is rare for a passive owner.
The competing rule, Cal. Code Regs. tit. 18, § 17951-4(d), apportions a nonresident partner’s distributive share of a multistate partnership’s business income using the partnership’s California factors. It governs income from running the business, not selling the interest.
The overlap comes from 26 U.S.C. § 751(a), which treats the part of your price attributable to unrealized receivables and inventory (“hot assets”) as realized from “property other than a capital asset,” meaning ordinary income. After Burch and Carden, a nonresident who held the interest directly sources all of the gain, hot-asset slice included, to his or her home state.
Why did the OTA reject FTB Legal Ruling 2022-02?
FTB issued Legal Ruling 2022-02 on July 14, 2022. Relying on Appeal of Bense, 79-SBE-055 (1979), it treated one sale as two: the partnership is deemed to sell its section 751 property first, and that piece becomes a distributive share apportioned under regulation 17951-4.
The appellants were nonresidents who owned JCB Investments, LLC, a partnership holding about 28 percent of Tory Burch LLC. JCB sold parts of that stake in 2012 and 2013, and FTB sourced the hot-asset portion at Tory Burch’s 13.5581 and 16.0753 percent California factors. The dollars were small: $1,507 of 2012 tax for the Cardens and a $2,535,814 cut to Mr. Burch’s net operating loss. The hearing transcript shows FTB issued the ruling after the protest hearing and before its determination.
Administrative Law Judge Kenneth Gast’s opinion followed Rawat v. Commissioner, 108 F.4th 891 (D.C. Cir. 2024), which held that “§ 751(a) does not treat inventory gain as gain from the sale of inventory.” Section 751(a) changes character, not the transaction. The panel called Rawat “highly persuasive,” read Bense as a case about California residents, limited regulation 17951-4(d) to distributive shares, and “declines to follow FTB Legal Ruling 2022-02.”
The panel never called FTB’s view unwise. It found no statute or regulation supporting it, and recalled that the Legislature changed the rule for corporate partners in 1988 after FTB lost Appeal of Holiday Inns. I read that as an invitation.
Can I get back California tax I already paid on hot-asset gain?
Possibly. Under Rev. & Tax. Code § 19306, a claim is timely through the latest of four years from filing a timely return (extensions count), four years from the original due date, or one year from payment. A 2022 return filed on extension in October 2023 stays open into October 2027.
FTB also accepts protective claims when an outcome depends on pending matters; individuals check the protective claim box on the amended return. A claim FTB leaves unanswered for six months is deemed denied, and you can then appeal to the OTA or sue. If you are already in a protest or an OTA appeal, put Burch and Carden before the protest officer or panel in writing now.
As of October 30, 2026: either side had 30 days to seek rehearing (Rev. & Tax. Code § 19334; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 18, § 30602), and I found no rehearing opinion. In October the OTA listed the case as “Pending Precedential.” Under Cal. Code Regs. tit. 18, § 30502, it becomes precedential or nonprecedential 35 to 60 days after posting, so expect an answer around December. FTB still lists Legal Ruling 2022-02 without a withdrawal note, and I found no bill amending section 17952. Watch those three things, but don’t let a four-year window close while waiting for FTB to concede.
Did you get an FTB notice about a partnership sale, or sell an LLC interest after leaving California? Refund periods run from your own filing and payment dates, not from whenever FTB settles its view of Burch and Carden.
Does Burch and Carden help if I sold through a holding LLC or an S corporation?
Often not. In Appeal of Smith, 2023-OTA-069P, a holding LLC owned 50.50 percent of a timeshare company, and one man managed both. The OTA found them unitary and apportioned the holding company’s gain with the operating company’s factors, sustaining a $176,936 assessment. The 2009 Metropoulos Family Trust v. Franchise Tax Board, 79 Cal. App. 5th 245 (2022), taxed nonresident trusts on their S corporation’s asset-sale gain as apportioned business income.
Burch distinguished both because FTB “does not argue JCB and Tory Burch are unitary.” JCB was itself a holding partnership, so that concession mattered. Under a unitary structure the whole gain is apportioned, not only the hot-asset slice.
Legal Ruling 2022-02 addresses partnerships, not S corporation stock, and the panel contrasted section 751 with section 338 deemed asset sales. A single-member LLC is disregarded in California too (Rev. & Tax. Code § 23038(b)(2)), so selling it is selling its assets.
Will FTB argue I never left California instead?
Expect it. The Burch appellants’ nonresidency was undisputed; yours may not be. Under Rev. & Tax. Code § 17014, a resident includes anyone here “for other than a temporary or transitory purpose,” and residents are taxed on the entire gain.
Sourcing touches only the hot-asset slice; residency reaches everything. When a sale closes within a year or two of a move, I expect FTB to test the move first, which is why the paperwork of leaving matters as much as the sale documents. My post on FTB residency audits after moving to Texas or Nevada covers how those audits run.
What would this mean for a Temecula distributor sale?
Illustrative facts: Devin moved from Irvine to Reno in March 2024, selling the house and moving the family. In 2026 he sells his 20 percent interest in a Temecula wine distributor LLC taxed as a partnership, for a $900,000 gain, $250,000 of it attributable to inventory and receivables under section 751(a). The distributor’s California apportionment is 90 percent. Devin is single, with $150,000 of Nevada salary.
Under the FTB ruling, $225,000 is California income. Section 17041(b) taxes a nonresident at his average rate on all income: using the 2025 schedule as a stand-in, tax on $1,050,000 is $109,987 (about 10.47 percent), or roughly $23,569 on $225,000 before credits. The 1 percent Behavioral Health Services Tax (Rev. & Tax. Code § 17043) applies only above $1 million of California taxable income, so it does not apply. Under Burch and Carden, the California tax is zero.
Now suppose Devin held through a management LLC that also ran the distributor. That looks like Smith: if the gain is business income at that level, $810,000 (90 percent of the full gain) is California income, and the tax at the same average rate is about $84,847. A structural choice made years before the sale moves the answer from zero to five figures.
| Situation | FTB Legal Ruling 2022-02 position | Burch and Carden result | What decides it | Refund posture |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct interest, nonresident on sale date | Hot-asset gain apportioned at partnership factors | All gain sourced to domicile (§ 17952) | No California business situs | Claim while § 19306 is open |
| Held through a unitary holding entity | Same | No help; Smith controls | Shared management and dependency | Weak unless not unitary |
| California resident on sale date | Irrelevant | No help | Residency under § 17014 | Fight is residency |
| S corporation stock (compare Metropoulos) | Not addressed | Not addressed | Actual or deemed asset sale | Little here |
| Single-member LLC | Not applicable | Not applicable | Asset sale (§ 23038) | None here |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Burch and Carden binding on the Franchise Tax Board?
Not by itself. If designated precedential it can be cited in other OTA appeals. Nothing in it orders auditors to stop using Legal Ruling 2022-02.
I sold my interest years ago. Is it too late?
Count from your actual filing and payment dates. Section 19306 allows the latest of four years from a timely return, four years from the due date, or one year from payment.
Does the decision help a California resident?
No. Residents are taxed on all income regardless of source. The decision matters only if you were a nonresident on the sale date.
What counts as a hot asset under section 751?
Mainly unrealized receivables and inventory, as sections 751(c) and 751(d) define those terms; the definitions also reach some depreciation recapture. The partnership’s year-of-sale statement should show the amount.
Should I file a regular refund claim or a protective claim?
If you held the interest directly and paid tax on the hot-asset slice, a regular claim citing Burch and Carden is reasonable. A protective claim fits when your outcome depends on something pending. Either must beat the deadline.
How North Star Law Firm Can Help
North Star Law Firm reviews how a former Californian’s partnership sale was reported, prepares refund and protective claims, and handles protests and Office of Tax Appeals cases. When FTB attacks the move instead, the firm defends residency through FTB tax defense, and for owners who have not sold it reviews holding structures through business sale tax structuring. Phillip Zagotti is a California attorney and a CPA admitted to the U.S. Tax Court.
If you sold an interest after leaving California or have an FTB notice in hand, contact North Star Law Firm or schedule a consultation before your refund window closes.
